Zaghloul Ashraf Ahmad, Rahman Syed Azizur, Abou El-Enein Nagwa Younes
Health Policy, Planning and Administration, Department of Public Health Administration and Behavioural Sciences, High Institute of Public Health, University of Alexandria, Alexandria, Egypt.
Chair of Health Services Administration Department, College of Health Science, University of Sharjah, Sharjah, United Arab Emirates.
Int J Risk Saf Med. 2016 Aug 22;28(2):93-9. doi: 10.3233/JRS-160722.
The study aimed to identify healthcare providers' obligation towards medical errors disclosure as well as to study the association between the severity of the medical error and the intention to disclose the error to the patients and their families.
A cross-sectional study design was followed to identify the magnitude of disclosure among healthcare providers in different departments at a randomly selected tertiary care hospital in Dubai.
The total sample size accounted for 106 respondents. Data were collected using a questionnaire composed of two sections namely; demographic variables of the respondents and a section which included variables relevant to medical error disclosure.
Statistical analysis yielded significant association between the obligation to disclose medical errors with male healthcare providers (X2 = 5.1), and being a physician (X2 = 19.3). Obligation towards medical errors disclosure was significantly associated with those healthcare providers who had not committed any medical errors during the past year (X2 = 9.8), and any type of medical error regardless the cause, extent of harm (X2 = 8.7). Variables included in the binary logistic regression model were; status (Exp β (Physician) = 0.39, 95% CI 0.16-0.97), gender (Exp β (Male) = 4.81, 95% CI 1.84-12.54), and medical errors during the last year (Exp β (None) = 2.11, 95% CI 0.6-2.3).
Education and training of physicians about disclosure conversations needs to start as early as medical school. Like the training in other competencies required of physicians, education in communicating about medical errors could help reduce physicians' apprehension and make them more comfortable with disclosure conversations.
本研究旨在确定医疗服务提供者对医疗差错披露的义务,并研究医疗差错的严重程度与向患者及其家属披露差错的意愿之间的关联。
采用横断面研究设计,以确定迪拜一家随机选择的三级护理医院不同科室医疗服务提供者的披露程度。
总样本量为106名受访者。使用一份由两部分组成的问卷收集数据,即受访者的人口统计学变量和包括与医疗差错披露相关变量的部分。
统计分析得出,男性医疗服务提供者(X2 = 5.1)以及医生(X2 = 19.3)在医疗差错披露义务方面存在显著关联。对医疗差错披露的义务与过去一年未发生任何医疗差错的医疗服务提供者(X2 = 9.8)以及任何类型的医疗差错(无论原因、伤害程度如何)(X2 = 8.7)显著相关。二元逻辑回归模型中的变量包括:身份(Exp β(医生)= 0.39,95%置信区间0.16 - (此处原文有误,应为0.97)0.97)、性别(Exp β(男性)= 4.81,95%置信区间1.84 - 12.54)以及过去一年中的医疗差错(Exp β(无)= 2.11,95%置信区间0.6 - 2.3)。
关于披露沟通的医生教育和培训应早在医学院阶段就开始。如同对医生所需其他能力的培训一样,关于医疗差错沟通的教育有助于减轻医生的担忧,并使他们在披露沟通时更加自在。