Haac Bryce, Rock Clare, Harris Anthony D, Pineles Lisa, Stein Deborah, Scalea Thomas, Hu Peter, Hagegeorge George, Liang Stephen Y, Thom Kerri A
R Adams Cowley Shock Trauma Center, University of Maryland Medical Center, 22 South Greene St., Baltimore, MD 21201, United States.
Department of Medicine, Division of Infectious Diseases, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Halsted 831, 600 N. Wolfe Street, Baltimore, MD 21287, United States.
Injury. 2017 Jan;48(1):165-170. doi: 10.1016/j.injury.2016.08.004. Epub 2016 Aug 17.
Healthcare-associated infections are a significant health burden, and hand hygiene (HH) is an essential prevention strategy. World Health Organization (WHO) 2009 guidelines recommend washing hands during five moments of patient care; 1)before touching a patient; 2)before a clean procedure; 3)after body fluid exposure; and 4)after touching a patient or 5)patient surroundings. HH opportunities at these 5 moments are frequent and compliance is low (22-60%). Infection risk is particularly high in trauma patients, and HH compliance during active trauma resuscitation has yet to be evaluated.
Using video surveillance, all healthcare worker (HCW)-patient interactions for 30 patients were retrospectively reviewed for HH compliance according to WHO guidelines and glove use during initial resuscitation at a level-1 trauma center.
342 HCW-patient interactions and 1034 HH opportunities were observed. HH compliance with the WHO moments was 7% (71/1034) overall; 3% (10/375) before patient contact, 0% (0/178) before a clean procedure, 11% (2/19) after body fluid contact, 15% (57/376) after patient contact and 2% (2/86) after contact with the environment. Glove use was more common, particularly before (69%) and after (47%) patient contact and after body fluid contact (58%). No HH was observed before clean procedures, but HCW donned new gloves 75% of the time before bedside procedures. If donning/removing gloves was included with HH as compliant, compliance was 57% overall.
HH opportunities are frequent and compliance with WHO HH guidelines may be infeasible, requiring significant amounts of time that may be better spent with the patient during the golden hour of trauma resuscitation. In an era where more scrutiny is being applied to patient safety, particularly the prevention of inpatient infections, more research is needed to identify alternative strategies (e.g. glove use, prioritizing moments) that may more effectively promote compliance in this setting.
医疗保健相关感染是一项重大的健康负担,手部卫生(HH)是一项基本的预防策略。世界卫生组织(WHO)2009年的指南建议在患者护理的五个时刻洗手;1)接触患者前;2)进行清洁操作前;3)体液暴露后;4)接触患者后或5)接触患者周围环境后。这五个时刻的手部卫生机会频繁,但依从性较低(22%-60%)。创伤患者的感染风险特别高,而在积极的创伤复苏过程中的手部卫生依从性尚未得到评估。
在一家一级创伤中心,通过视频监控对30名患者的所有医护人员(HCW)与患者的互动进行回顾性审查,以评估根据WHO指南的手部卫生依从性以及初始复苏期间的手套使用情况。
观察到342次医护人员与患者的互动以及1034次手部卫生机会。总体而言,符合WHO时刻的手部卫生依从性为7%(71/1034);接触患者前为3%(10/375),进行清洁操作前为0%(0/178),体液接触后为11%(2/19),接触患者后为15%(57/376),接触环境后为2%(2/86)。手套使用更为常见,特别是在接触患者前(69%)和后(47%)以及体液接触后(58%)。在清洁操作前未观察到手部卫生行为,但医护人员在床边操作前75%的时间会戴上新手套。如果将戴/脱手套视为符合手部卫生要求,总体依从性为57%。
手部卫生机会频繁,遵循WHO手部卫生指南可能不可行,这需要大量时间,而在创伤复苏的黄金时段,这些时间可能更好地用于照顾患者。在一个对患者安全,特别是预防住院患者感染进行更多审查的时代,需要更多研究来确定替代策略(如使用手套、确定优先时刻),这些策略可能在这种情况下更有效地促进依从性。