School of Environmental Sciences, University of Guelph, Guelph, Ontario N1G 2W1, Canada.
Ottawa Research and Development Centre, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, K.W. Neatby Building, Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0C6, Canada.
Sci Total Environ. 2016 Dec 15;573:356-365. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.08.153. Epub 2016 Aug 26.
Effective management of nitrogen (N) fertilizer application by farmers provides great potential for reducing emissions of the potent greenhouse gas nitrous oxide (NO). However, such potential is rarely achieved because our understanding of what practices (or combination of practices) lead to NO reductions without compromising crop yields remains far from complete. Using scenario analysis with the process-based model DNDC, this study explored the effects of nine fertilizer practices on NO emissions and crop yields from two corn production systems in Canada. The scenarios differed in: timing of fertilizer application, fertilizer rate, number of applications, fertilizer type, method of application and use of nitrification/urease inhibitors. Statistical analysis showed that during the initial calibration and validation stages the simulated results had no significant total error or bias compared to measured values, yet grain yield estimations warrant further model improvement. Sidedress fertilizer applications reduced yield-scaled NO emissions by c. 60% compared to fall fertilization. Nitrification inhibitors further reduced yield-scaled NO emissions by c. 10%; urease inhibitors had no effect on either NO emissions or crop productivity. The combined adoption of split fertilizer application with inhibitors at a rate 10% lower than the conventional application rate (i.e. 150kgNha) was successful, but the benefits were lower than those achieved with single fertilization at sidedress. Our study provides a comprehensive assessment of fertilizer management practices that enables policy development regarding NO mitigation from agricultural soils in Canada.
农民有效管理氮肥(N)的施用,为减少强温室气体一氧化二氮(NO)的排放提供了巨大的潜力。然而,由于我们对哪些实践(或实践的组合)可以在不影响作物产量的情况下减少 NO 排放的理解还远远不够完整,因此这种潜力很少得到实现。本研究使用基于过程的模型 DNDC 进行情景分析,探讨了在加拿大两种玉米生产系统中,九种肥料管理实践对 NO 排放和作物产量的影响。这些情景在施肥时间、施肥率、施肥次数、肥料类型、施肥方式和硝化/脲酶抑制剂的使用方面存在差异。统计分析表明,在初始校准和验证阶段,模拟结果与实测值相比没有显著的总误差或偏差,但谷物产量估算需要进一步改进模型。与秋季施肥相比,侧施肥料可将产量标准化的 NO 排放量减少约 60%。硝化抑制剂可进一步将产量标准化的 NO 排放量减少约 10%;脲酶抑制剂对 NO 排放或作物生产力均无影响。与常规施肥相比,抑制剂的分施率降低 10%(即 150kgNha)的联合施肥方式是成功的,但与侧施单一施肥方式相比,其效益较低。本研究提供了对肥料管理实践的全面评估,为加拿大农业土壤中减少 NO 排放的政策制定提供了依据。