Lancioni Giulio E, Singh Nirbhay N, O'Reilly Mark F, Sigafoos Jeff, D'Amico Fiora, Buonocunto Francesca, Navarro Jorge, Lanzilotti Crocifissa, Fiore Pietro, Megna Marisa, Damiani Sabino, Marvulli Riccardo
Department of Neuroscience and Sense Organs, University of Bari, Bari, Italy -
Medical College of Georgia, Augusta University, Augusta, GA, USA.
Eur J Phys Rehabil Med. 2017 Jun;53(3):433-440. doi: 10.23736/S1973-9087.16.04324-0. Epub 2016 Sep 1.
Postcoma persons in a minimally conscious state (MCS) and with extensive motor impairment cannot independently access and control environmental stimulation.
Assessing the effects of a microswitch-aided program aimed at helping MCS persons develop responding and stimulation control and conducting a social validation/evaluation of the program.
A single-subject ABAB design was used for each participant to determine the impact of the program on his or her responding. Staff interviews were used for the social validation/evaluation of the program.
Rehabilitation and care facilities that the participants attended.
Eleven MCS persons with extensive motor impairment and lack of speech or any other functional communication.
For each participant, baseline (A) phases were alternated with intervention (B) phases during which the program was used. The program relied on microswitches to monitor participants' specific responses (e.g., prolonged eyelid closures) and on a computer system to enable those responses to control stimulation. In practice, the participants could use a simple response such as prolonged eyelid closure to generate a new stimulation input. Sixty-six staff people took part in the social validation of the program. They were to compare the program to basic and elaborate forms of externally controlled stimulation, scoring each of them on a six-item questionnaire.
All participants showed increased response frequencies (and thus higher levels of independent stimulation input/control) during the B phases of the study. Their frequencies for each intervention phase more than doubled their frequencies for the preceding baseline phase with the difference between the two being clearly significant (P<0.01). Staff involved in the social validation procedure provided significantly higher scoring (P<0.01) for the program on five of the six questionnaire items.
A microswitch-aided program can be an effective and socially acceptable tool in the work with MCS persons.
The participants and staff's data can be taken as an encouragement for the use of a microswitch-aided program within care and rehabilitation settings for MCS persons.
处于微意识状态(MCS)且有严重运动障碍的昏迷后患者无法独立获取和控制环境刺激。
评估一项旨在帮助微意识状态患者发展反应能力和刺激控制能力的微动开关辅助计划的效果,并对该计划进行社会验证/评估。
采用单受试者ABAB设计,以确定该计划对每位参与者反应的影响。通过工作人员访谈对该计划进行社会验证/评估。
参与者接受治疗的康复和护理机构。
11名有严重运动障碍且无言语或其他功能性交流的微意识状态患者。
对每位参与者,基线(A)阶段与使用该计划的干预(B)阶段交替进行。该计划依靠微动开关监测参与者的特定反应(如长时间闭眼),并通过计算机系统使这些反应能够控制刺激。实际上,参与者可以用诸如长时间闭眼这样简单的反应来产生新的刺激输入。66名工作人员参与了该计划的社会验证。他们将该计划与外部控制刺激的基本形式和精细形式进行比较,并在一份六项问卷上对每种形式进行评分。
在研究的B阶段,所有参与者的反应频率均增加(从而独立刺激输入/控制水平更高)。每个干预阶段的频率比前一个基线阶段的频率增加了一倍多,两者之间的差异非常显著(P<0.01)。参与社会验证程序的工作人员在六项问卷中的五项上对该计划给出了显著更高的评分(P<0.01)。
微动开关辅助计划可能是针对微意识状态患者开展工作的一种有效且为社会所接受的工具。
参与者和工作人员的数据可作为在护理和康复环境中对微意识状态患者使用微动开关辅助计划的一种鼓励。