Garzon Mauricio, Dupuy Olivier, Bosquet Laurent, Nigam Anil, Comtois Alain Steve, Juneau Martin, Gayda Mathieu
a Cardiovascular Prevention and Rehabilitation Centre (EPIC), Montreal Heart Institute , Montreal , Quebec , Canada.
b Research Center, Montreal Heart Institute, University of Montreal , Montreal , Quebec , Canada.
Eur J Sport Sci. 2017 Apr;17(3):310-316. doi: 10.1080/17461391.2016.1226391. Epub 2016 Sep 6.
This study compared heart rate recovery (HRR) after incremental maximal exercise performed at the same external power output (P) on dry land ergocycle (DE) vs. immersible ergocycle (IE). Fifteen young healthy participants (30 ± 7 years, 13 men and 2 women) performed incremental maximal exercise tests on DE and on IE. The initial P on DE was 25 W and was increased by 25 W/min at a pedalling cadence between 60 and 80 rpm, while during IE immersion at chest level in thermoneutral water (30°C), the initial P deployment was at a cadence of 40 rpm which was increased by 10 rpm until 70 rpm and thereafter by 5 rpm until exhaustion. Gas exchange and heart rate (HR) were measured continuously during exercise and recovery for 5 min. Maximal HR (DE: 176 ± 15 vs. IE 169 ± 12 bpm) reached by the subjects in the two conditions did not differ (P > .05). Parasympathetic reactivation parameters (ΔHR from 10 to 300 s) were compared during the DE and IE HR recovery recordings. During the IE recovery, parasympathetic reactivation in the early phase was more predominant (HRR at Δ10-Δ60 s, P < .05), but similar in the late phase (HRR at Δ120-Δ300 s, P > .05) when compared to the DE condition. In conclusion, incremental maximal IE exercise at chest level immersion in thermoneutral water accelerates the early phase parasympathetic reactivation compared to DE in healthy young participants.
本研究比较了在相同外部功率输出(P)下,在陆地测力计(DE)和可浸入式测力计(IE)上进行递增最大运动后的心率恢复(HRR)情况。15名年轻健康参与者(30±7岁,13名男性和2名女性)在DE和IE上进行了递增最大运动测试。DE上的初始功率为25W,以每分钟25W的速度递增,蹬踏节奏为60至80转/分钟,而在IE中,参与者胸部水平浸入热中性水(30°C)时,初始功率设置为40转/分钟,以10转/分钟的速度递增至70转/分钟,此后以5转/分钟的速度递增直至力竭。在运动和恢复的5分钟内持续测量气体交换和心率(HR)。两种情况下受试者达到的最大心率(DE:176±15与IE 169±12次/分钟)无差异(P>.05)。在DE和IE的心率恢复记录过程中,比较了副交感神经再激活参数(从10至300秒的ΔHR)。在IE恢复过程中,早期阶段副交感神经再激活更为显著(Δ10-Δ60秒时的HRR,P<.05),但与DE情况相比,后期阶段相似(Δ120-Δ300秒时的HRR,P>.05)。总之,对于健康年轻参与者,在胸部水平浸入热中性水中进行递增最大IE运动与DE相比,可加速早期阶段的副交感神经再激活。