Kip Kevin E, D'Aoust Rita F, Hernandez Diego F, Girling Sue Ann, Cuttino Barrett, Long Mary Kathryn, Rojas Paola, Wittenberg Trudy, Abhayakumar Alisha, Rosenzweig Laney
University of South Florida, College of Nursing, Tampa, FL.
University of South Florida, College of Nursing, Tampa, FL.
Nurs Outlook. 2016 Sep-Oct;64(5):411-23. doi: 10.1016/j.outlook.2016.04.006. Epub 2016 May 7.
Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is prevalent in both homeless and nonhomeless veterans.
To examine unique characteristics of being homeless that may influence PTSD treatment completion and clinical success.
Twenty-three veterans who were homeless and residing in a homeless shelter, along with 94 veterans from the community, were enrolled to receive one to five sessions of Accelerated Resolution Therapy (ART), an emerging trauma-focused therapy for symptoms of PTSD. Rates of treatment completion with ART and acute and 6-month change in symptoms of PTSD were compared in an observational (nonrandomized) manner by housing status.
Compared to veterans recruited from the community, veterans residing in the homeless shelter were older and presented with more extensive psychopathology yet had less combat exposure while being more likely to have experienced sexual assault. Rates of treatment completion were 52.2% (12 of 23) among homeless veterans compared to 81.9% (77 of 94) among veterans from the community (p = .005). Among treatment completers, both groups received an average of four sessions of ART. Reduction of symptoms of PTSD was substantial and nonsignificantly greater among homeless veterans vs. those treated from the community (p = .14), as were comorbidity reductions in depression, anxiety, sleep quality, pain, and improved quality of life. Results at 6-month posttreatment follow-up were similar.
Although limited by small sample size and a nonrandomized design, ART appears to be an effective, brief treatment for symptoms of PTSD among veterans residing in a homeless shelter. However, development of effective strategies to maximize treatment completion among homeless veterans is needed.
创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)在无家可归和有家可归的退伍军人中都很普遍。
研究无家可归状态可能影响PTSD治疗完成率和临床疗效的独特特征。
招募了23名居住在收容所的无家可归退伍军人以及94名来自社区的退伍军人,接受1至5次加速解决疗法(ART),这是一种针对PTSD症状的新兴创伤聚焦疗法。通过住房状况以观察性(非随机)方式比较ART的治疗完成率以及PTSD症状在急性期和6个月时的变化。
与从社区招募的退伍军人相比,居住在收容所的退伍军人年龄更大,精神病理学表现更广泛,但战斗经历较少,同时更有可能遭受性侵犯。无家可归退伍军人的治疗完成率为52.2%(23人中的12人),而社区退伍军人为81.9%(94人中的77人)(p = .005)。在完成治疗的患者中,两组平均接受了4次ART治疗。无家可归退伍军人的PTSD症状减轻幅度很大,与社区治疗的退伍军人相比虽无显著差异(p = .14),抑郁、焦虑、睡眠质量、疼痛等合并症的减轻情况以及生活质量的改善也是如此。治疗后6个月随访的结果相似。
尽管样本量小且设计非随机存在局限性,但ART似乎是治疗居住在收容所的退伍军人PTSD症状的一种有效、简短的治疗方法。然而,需要制定有效的策略以最大限度地提高无家可归退伍军人的治疗完成率。