Ye Ting, Niehoff Jens-Uwe, Zhang Yan, Zhang Liang
School of Medicine and Health Management, Tongji Medical College, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, China.
Saluscon Akademie, Berlin, Germany, Visiting Professor School of Medicine and Health Management, Tongji Medical College, Wuhan, China.
Gesundheitswesen. 2017 Jan;79(1):e10-e17. doi: 10.1055/s-0042-111824. Epub 2016 Sep 7.
China's healthcare system is developing very fast but needs a regulatory practice, which helps to improve effectiveness and efficiency. This is a problem in rural China, in particular. The government is promoting a providing system with gatekeeping and mandatory referral procedures in order to limit resulting problems. However, there exists little evidence, which of the primary healthcare facilities in rural China should be given these functions. It is this study's objective to determine the impact of the specific medical institution of an initial visit on the patients' following move through the healthcare system. On that reason, we want to find evidence which level of primary health sectors in rural China is more appropriate to perform gatekeeping and to integrate care based on referrals. The alternatives are either to prefer village clinics or township health centers. The data were collected through a cross-sectional study in 2012, which used a stratified random sampling method to select 4 counties. 420 patients who wanted to see the doctors more than 3 times during the past 6 months were included as the study sample. We described the patients' move through the healthcare system by measuring the density, dispersion and sequence of visits according to the Continuity of Care model (COC). The logistic regression model was used to determine the influence of medical institution of initial visit on patients' moves after controlling other variables. We found that patients who chose the county hospital as medical institution for their initial visit had 5.88 times of the odds of high (vs. low) density, 4.17 times the odds of high (vs. low) dispersion, and 2.86 times the odds of high (vs. low) sequence of visits than those choosing village clinics as medical institution for the initial visit. However, patients choosing the county hospitals as medical institution of initial visit did not report higher density, dispersion or sequence of visit than the patients who chose the township health centers. For the overwhelming majority of rural areas in China, the township health centers are more appropriate to perform the gatekeeping role than village clinics are. We see that as the conclusion at least at the present stage of the system's development.
中国的医疗体系发展迅速,但需要规范实践,以提高有效性和效率。这在中国农村地区尤其是个问题。政府正在推广一种带有守门和强制转诊程序的提供体系,以限制由此产生的问题。然而,几乎没有证据表明中国农村的哪些基层医疗设施应被赋予这些功能。本研究的目的是确定初次就诊的特定医疗机构对患者后续在医疗体系中的就医行为的影响。基于这个原因,我们想找到证据,证明中国农村哪个层级的基层医疗部门更适合履行守门职责并整合基于转诊的医疗服务。可供选择的是村卫生室或乡镇卫生院。数据是通过2012年的一项横断面研究收集的,该研究采用分层随机抽样方法选取了4个县。420名在过去6个月内就诊次数超过3次的患者被纳入研究样本。我们根据连续性医疗模型(COC),通过测量就诊的密度、离散度和顺序来描述患者在医疗体系中的就医行为。在控制其他变量后,使用逻辑回归模型来确定初次就诊医疗机构对患者就医行为的影响。我们发现,选择县级医院作为初次就诊医疗机构的患者,其高密度(与低密度相比)就诊几率是选择村卫生室作为初次就诊医疗机构患者的5.88倍,高离散度(与低离散度相比)就诊几率是4.17倍,高就诊顺序(与低就诊顺序相比)几率是2.86倍。然而,选择县级医院作为初次就诊医疗机构的患者,其就诊密度、离散度或就诊顺序并不高于选择乡镇卫生院的患者。对于中国绝大多数农村地区而言,乡镇卫生院比村卫生室更适合履行守门职责。至少在现阶段的体系发展中,我们将此视为结论。