Thompson A H, Bland R C, Orn H T
Alberta Mental Health Services, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada.
J Nerv Ment Dis. 1989 Aug;177(8):456-63. doi: 10.1097/00005053-198908000-00002.
The comorbidity of disorders and chronology of first symptoms of depression, agoraphobia, and panic disorder were investigated. The Diagnostic Interview Schedule was administered to 3258 household residents. Strong associations were shown among all three disorders. However, the comorbidity of agoraphobia and panic disorder seemed to be accounted for by the relationship of both disorders with depression. The mean age at appearance of first symptoms was earlier for agoraphobia (low teens) than for depression or panic disorder (both about age 20). The results do not support the view that panic disorder is an integral component of agoraphobia, but rather that it is more closely associated with depression. The fact that agoraphobia precedes depression casts doubt on the thesis that depression is primary to anxiety disorders. Interpretation should, however, be viewed with caution because of the retrospective nature of the diagnostic instrument.
对抑郁症、广场恐惧症和惊恐障碍的共病情况以及首发症状的时间顺序进行了调查。对3258名住户居民进行了诊断访谈表调查。结果显示这三种障碍之间存在很强的关联。然而,广场恐惧症和惊恐障碍的共病似乎是由这两种障碍与抑郁症的关系所导致的。广场恐惧症首发症状出现时的平均年龄(十几岁早期)比抑郁症或惊恐障碍(均约为20岁)更早。研究结果不支持惊恐障碍是广场恐惧症一个不可或缺组成部分的观点,而是表明它与抑郁症的联系更为紧密。广场恐惧症先于抑郁症出现这一事实对抑郁症是焦虑症的原发性疾病这一论点提出了质疑。然而,由于诊断工具具有回顾性,对结果的解释应谨慎看待。