Busenlechner Dieter, Mailath-Pokorny Georg, Haas Robert, Fürhauser Rudolf, Eder Carina, Pommer Bernhard, Watzek Georg
Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants. 2016 Sep-Oct;31(5):1150-5. doi: 10.11607/jomi.4326.
To compare long-term survival and marginal bone loss of immediate interantral implants in the nonaugmented maxilla subjected to immediate vs delayed loading.
Graftless maxillary cross-arch rehabilitation was performed in a total of 362 patients in the years 2004 to 2013 (1,797 implants). Of the 240 patients with immediate implants replacing their failing maxillary dentition, 81% were subjected to immediate loading and 19% to delayed loading of their 4 to 6 interantral implants (980 and 235 implants, respectively). Kaplan-Meier survival estimates were computed and marginal bone loss was evaluated in a stratified random sample of 20 patients per group.
Thirty-one of 1,215 implants failed within the mean observation period of 3.9 years, and no difference in 8-year survival estimates could be seen between immediate (97.6% [95% CI: 96.7 to 98.6]) and delayed (96.6% [95% CI: 94.3 to 98.9]) loading protocols (P = .359). Mean marginal bone resorption following implant insertion did not differ significantly between the groups (1.5 ± 1.7 mm vs 0.7 ± 1.1 mm, P = .379); however, it was significantly associated with a reduced number of implants (P = .017) and patient history of periodontal disease (P < .001).
Immediate loading of interantral implants yields satisfactory results in the transition of patients from a failing maxillary dentition to full-arch implant rehabilitation and thus may be favored over delayed loading concepts.
比较在未行上颌窦底提升的上颌骨中,即刻种植体即刻负重与延期负重后的长期生存率及边缘骨吸收情况。
2004年至2013年期间,共对362例患者进行了无植骨的上颌跨牙弓修复(1797枚种植体)。在240例用即刻种植体替代上颌失败牙列的患者中,81%的患者对其4至6枚上颌窦内种植体(分别为980枚和235枚)进行了即刻负重,19%的患者进行了延期负重。计算Kaplan-Meier生存率估计值,并在每组20例患者的分层随机样本中评估边缘骨吸收情况。
在平均3.9年的观察期内,1215枚种植体中有31枚失败,即刻负重(97.6%[95%CI:96.7至98.6])和延期负重(96.6%[95%CI:94.3至98.9])方案的8年生存率估计值无差异(P = 0.359)。种植体植入后的平均边缘骨吸收在两组间无显著差异(1.5±1.7mm对0.7±1.1mm,P = 0.379);然而,它与种植体数量减少(P = 0.017)和患者牙周病史(P < 0.001)显著相关。
上颌窦内种植体即刻负重能使患者从失败的上颌牙列顺利过渡到全牙弓种植修复,效果令人满意,因此可能比延期负重理念更具优势。