Webb Tamsyn R, Rajendran Dévan
Research Department, European School of Osteopathy, Boxley House, Boxley, Maidstone, Kent, ME14 3DZ, UK.
J Bodyw Mov Ther. 2016 Jul;20(3):682-99. doi: 10.1016/j.jbmt.2016.02.013. Epub 2016 Mar 2.
This systematic review aimed to determine the evidence for the effect of a single manually applied myofascial technique (MFT) on joint range of motion (JROM) and pain in non-pathological symptomatic subjects.
Authors independently searched the following databases: PEDro; Cochrane Library; NLM PubMed; EMBASE; Academic Search Premier; MEDLINE; Psychology and Behavioural Sciences Collection; PsycINFO; SPORTSDiscus; CINAHL Plus from 2003 to 2015. All randomised controlled trials (RCTs) that used JROM as an outcome measure were identified. RCT quality was independently evaluated using PEDro and Cochrane Risk of Bias tools and all reported outcome data were independently abstracted and presented. If post-intervention central tendencies and variance were reported, these were assessed for heterogeneity with a view to performing a meta-analysis.
Nine RCTs (n = 534) were systematically reviewed and outcome data presented; all trials concluded that MFT increased JROM and reduced pain levels in symptomatic patients. Two RCTs (n = 161) were judged 'moderately' heterogeneous (I(2) = 47.2%; Cochran's Q = 5.69; p = 0.128, df = 3) and meta-analysis using a fixed effects model suggested a 'moderate' effect size of MFTs on jaw opening (ES = 0.578; 95%CI 0.302 to 0.853).
Although results reported by each RCT indicate that MFT increases JROM and reduces pain scores, there are a number of threats that challenge the statistical inferences underpinning these findings. Only two trials could be meta-analysed, the results of which suggest that applying MFTs to symptomatic patients diagnosed with latent trigger-points in masseter muscle can increase jaw JROM.
本系统评价旨在确定单一手动应用肌筋膜技术(MFT)对非病理性有症状受试者关节活动范围(JROM)和疼痛影响的证据。
作者独立检索了以下数据库:PEDro;Cochrane图书馆;美国国立医学图书馆(NLM)的PubMed;EMBASE;学术搜索高级版;MEDLINE;心理学与行为科学文集;PsycINFO;SPORTSDiscus;2003年至2015年的护理学与健康领域数据库(CINAHL Plus)。确定了所有将JROM作为结局指标的随机对照试验(RCT)。使用PEDro和Cochrane偏倚风险工具独立评估RCT质量,并独立提取和呈现所有报告的结局数据。如果报告了干预后的集中趋势和方差,则评估其异质性,以便进行荟萃分析。
对9项RCT(n = 534)进行了系统评价并呈现了结局数据;所有试验均得出结论,MFT可增加有症状患者的JROM并降低疼痛水平。两项RCT(n = 161)被判定为“中度”异质性(I² = 47.2%;Cochran's Q = 5.69;p = 0.128,自由度 = 3),使用固定效应模型的荟萃分析表明MFT对张口的效应大小为“中度”(效应量 = 0.578;95%可信区间0.302至0.853)。
尽管每项RCT报告的结果表明MFT可增加JROM并降低疼痛评分,但仍有一些因素对这些结果背后的统计推断构成挑战。仅两项试验可进行荟萃分析,其结果表明,对诊断为咬肌潜在触发点的有症状患者应用MFT可增加下颌JROM。