Kim S R, Lee J H, Park K H, Park H J, Park J W
Department of Internal Medicine, College of Medicine, Yonsei University, Seoul, Korea.
Clin Exp Allergy. 2017 Jan;47(1):106-112. doi: 10.1111/cea.12803. Epub 2016 Oct 12.
Low-osmolar non-ionic radiocontrast media (RCMs) are commonly used throughout hospitals. However, the incidence of immediate adverse drug reactions (ADRs) to various low-osmolar non-ionic RCMs is not well studied. We compared the incidence of immediate ADRs among different low-osmolar non-ionic RCMs used in computed tomography (CT).
Severance Hospital has collected data for adverse reactions occurring in-hospital using an internally developed system. Using this data, we reviewed 1969 immediate ADRs from 286 087 RCM-contrasted CT examinations of 142 099 patients and compared the immediate ADRs of iobitridol, iohexol, iopamidol, and iopromide. We analysed the incidence of immediate ADRs to different RCMs, as well as the effect of single or multiple CT examinations per day.
Iopromide showed the highest incidence of immediate ADRs (1.03%) and was followed by iopamidol (0.67%), iohexol (0.64%), and iobitridol (0.34%). In cases of anaphylaxis, iopromide also showed the highest incidence (0.041%), followed by iopamidol (0.023%), iohexol (0.018%), and iobitridol (0.012%). Risk of immediate ADR due to multiple CT examinations (1.19%) was significantly higher than the risk due to a single CT examination (0.63%). Risk of anaphylaxis was also higher for multiple CT examinations (0.052%) than for a single CT examination (0.020%).
The incidence of immediate ADRs varied according to the low-osmolar non-ionic RCM used. Iopromide-induced immediate ADRs were more frequent, while iobitridol was associated with fewer immediate ADRs than other RCMs. Multiple CT examinations per day resulted in a higher incidence of immediate ADRs and anaphylaxis than a single CT examination. Clinicians should consider these risk differences of immediate ADRs when prescribing contrasted CT examinations.
低渗非离子型放射性造影剂(RCMs)在医院中广泛使用。然而,对于各种低渗非离子型RCMs的即刻药物不良反应(ADRs)发生率尚未进行充分研究。我们比较了计算机断层扫描(CT)中使用的不同低渗非离子型RCMs之间即刻ADRs的发生率。
Severance医院使用内部开发的系统收集了院内发生的不良反应数据。利用这些数据,我们回顾了142099例患者的286087次RCM增强CT检查中的1969例即刻ADRs,并比较了碘克沙醇、碘海醇、碘帕醇和碘普罗胺的即刻ADRs。我们分析了不同RCMs即刻ADRs的发生率,以及每天进行单次或多次CT检查的影响。
碘普罗胺的即刻ADRs发生率最高(1.03%),其次是碘帕醇(0.67%)、碘海醇(0.64%)和碘克沙醇(0.34%)。在过敏反应病例中,碘普罗胺的发生率也最高(0.041%),其次是碘帕醇(0.023%)、碘海醇(0.018%)和碘克沙醇(0.012%)。多次CT检查导致即刻ADR的风险(1.19%)显著高于单次CT检查(0.63%)。多次CT检查的过敏反应风险(0.052%)也高于单次CT检查(0.020%)。
即刻ADRs的发生率因使用的低渗非离子型RCM而异。碘普罗胺引起的即刻ADRs更频繁,而碘克沙醇与其他RCM相比,即刻ADRs较少。每天进行多次CT检查导致即刻ADRs和过敏反应的发生率高于单次CT检查。临床医生在开具增强CT检查处方时应考虑这些即刻ADRs的风险差异。