Başaran Betül, Çelebioğlu Bilge, Başaran Ahmet, Altınel Seher, Kutlucan Leyla, Martin James N
Department of Anesthesiology, Konya Training and Research Hospital, Konya, Turkey.
Department of Anesthesiology, Hacettepe University School of Medicine, Ankara, Turkey.
J Turk Ger Gynecol Assoc. 2016 Sep 1;17(3):128-33. doi: 10.5152/jtgga.2016.16094. eCollection 2016.
Substantial controversy exists regarding anesthetic management for patients with preeclampsia or hemolysis, elevated liver enzymes, low platelet count (HELLP) syndrome. Experts, researchers, clinicians, and residents in Turkey were surveyed about their practices.
Questionnaires were distributed to attendees at a national conference, and they were filled out immediately. Anonymous 10-item paper surveys were administered to both residents and non-residents. Descriptive statistics were used in the analysis. Agreement among ≥75% of the respondents was considered a majority opinion. Surveys with missing responses were used to analyze the non-response bias. The Chi-square test was used for comparisons. A historical cohort of obstetricians-gynecologists was used for comparison with anesthesiologists.
Of 339 surveys distributed, 288 were returned (84.9% response rate). Among the returned surveys, the completion rate was 96.1%. The job experience in years among clinicians and residents was 9±5 and 3±1, respectively. General anesthesia was still significantly preferred by 36.1% among patients with preeclampsia with platelet counts of ≥100,000/μL. Compared to obstetricians-gynecologists, anesthesiologists more often preferred general anesthesia. With platelet counts of <50,000/μL or eclampsia, most respondents preferred general anesthesia 94.4% for very low platelets and 89.5% for eclampsia.
A preferential trend toward general anesthesia for patients with preeclampsia or HELLP syndrome exists among anesthesiologists in Turkey, particularly for patients with severe thrombocytopenia and/or eclampsia. There exists a need for well-designed and well-executed prospective clinical trials to provide evidence for the best consensus practice.
对于先兆子痫或溶血、肝酶升高、血小板减少(HELLP)综合征患者的麻醉管理存在大量争议。对土耳其的专家、研究人员、临床医生和住院医师的实践情况进行了调查。
向一次全国性会议的参会者发放问卷,并要求他们立即填写。对住院医师和非住院医师均进行了10项匿名纸质调查。分析采用描述性统计。≥75%的受访者达成一致被视为多数意见。对有缺失回答的调查进行分析以评估无应答偏倚。采用卡方检验进行比较。使用一组妇产科医生的历史队列与麻醉医生进行比较。
共发放339份调查问卷,回收288份(回复率84.9%)。在回收的调查问卷中,完成率为96.1%。临床医生和住院医师的工作年限分别为9±5年和3±1年。血小板计数≥100,000/μL的先兆子痫患者中,仍有36.1%的人显著更倾向于全身麻醉。与妇产科医生相比,麻醉医生更常倾向于全身麻醉。血小板计数<50,000/μL或子痫患者中,大多数受访者倾向于全身麻醉,血小板极低时为94.4%,子痫时为89.5%。
土耳其的麻醉医生中存在对先兆子痫或HELLP综合征患者倾向于全身麻醉的趋势,尤其是对于严重血小板减少和/或子痫患者。需要设计良好且执行良好的前瞻性临床试验来为最佳的共识实践提供证据。