Eberhard-Moscicka Aleksandra K, Jost Lea B, Fehlbaum Lynn V, Pfenninger Simone E, Maurer Urs
Department of Psychology, Division of Cognitive Neuroscience, University of Zurich, Switzerland; Neuroscience Center Zurich, University of Zurich and ETH Zurich, Switzerland.
Department of Psychology, Division of Cognitive Neuroscience, University of Zurich, Switzerland; Neuroscience Center Zurich, University of Zurich and ETH Zurich, Switzerland.
Neuropsychologia. 2016 Oct;91:509-518. doi: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2016.09.014. Epub 2016 Sep 19.
In the course of reading development children become familiar with letter strings and learn to distinguish between lexical and non-lexical items. In previous studies, the N1 component of the ERP was shown to reflect print tuning but also to be sensitive to lexical effects. It remains unclear, however, whether these two aspects of orthographic processing occur at the same time or in different time windows during the lengthy N1 component. Moreover, it is unclear whether these processes develop late or occur already at early stages of literacy acquisition and whether this is similar for native languages and languages acquired later in life. To address these questions, 27 children were tested longitudinally, i.e. before (mean: 7.6 years) and after one year of classroom-based English instruction. Additionally, 22 adult speakers of English as a foreign language (mean: 25.1 years) were investigated. A 128-channel EEG was recorded while participants performed a one-back task with native German words, English words, pseudowords and false-font strings. The event-related EEG analysis of early and late N1 phases revealed early effects related to print tuning and late effects related to lexical processing in the native, but not in the second language of adult readers. In the absence of lexicality effects in children, print tuning effects were found across both early and late N1 segments. The temporally distinct N1 sensitivities to print and lexicality reflect temporal dynamics of visual word processing, which seem to depend on reading expertise or maturation.
在阅读发展过程中,儿童会熟悉字母串,并学会区分词汇项和非词汇项。在先前的研究中,事件相关电位(ERP)的N1成分已被证明既能反映对印刷文字的适应,也对词汇效应敏感。然而,尚不清楚在较长的N1成分期间,正字法加工的这两个方面是同时发生还是在不同的时间窗口发生。此外,也不清楚这些过程是在后期发展还是在识字习得的早期阶段就已出现,以及对于母语和后期习得的语言来说是否类似。为了解决这些问题,对27名儿童进行了纵向测试,即在接受基于课堂的英语教学一年之前(平均年龄:7.6岁)和之后进行测试。此外,还对22名以英语为外语的成年人(平均年龄:25.1岁)进行了调查。在参与者对德语母语单词、英语单词、伪词和假字体字符串执行一项“1-back”任务时,记录了128通道脑电图(EEG)。对早期和晚期N1阶段的事件相关EEG分析显示,在成年读者的母语中,早期效应与对印刷文字的适应有关,晚期效应与词汇加工有关,但在第二语言中并非如此。在儿童中没有发现词汇效应的情况下,在早期和晚期N1段均发现了对印刷文字的适应效应。N1在时间上对印刷文字和词汇性的不同敏感性反映了视觉单词加工的时间动态,这似乎取决于阅读专业知识或成熟度。