Department of Dermatology, Henry Ford Hospital, Detroit, Michigan.
Michigan State University College of Osteopathic Medicine, East Lansing, Michigan.
J Am Acad Dermatol. 2016 Dec;75(6):1171-1175. doi: 10.1016/j.jaad.2016.07.012. Epub 2016 Sep 21.
For even seasoned practitioners, early melanomas can be difficult to distinguish from melanocytic nevi. Although serial digital dermoscopy is considered by many to be the gold standard for monitoring patients at high risk, poor compliance can seriously alter efficacy. In 2014, a concerning compliance rate of 25% was reported from a single, private clinic. Information is currently limited regarding the determinants of compliance and whether patients at high risk return at an acceptable rate.
We sought to determine the compliance rate within the pigmented lesions clinic at our academic institution and identify demographic variables that may influence adherence.
A retrospective review was conducted using 120 patient charts.
An overall compliance rate of 87.5% was observed with 63.3% of patients returning within 1 month of the recommended interval. The most notable risk factor for noncompliance was patient age between 20 and 29 years. Factors promoting adherence include a personal history of melanoma, greater than 5 serially monitored nevi, and a personal history of atypical nevi.
The external validity is limited and the sample size is small.
These findings contradict concerns that adherence to serial monitoring is unacceptably poor and demonstrate that compliance is highest for patients with the greatest inherent risk.
即使是经验丰富的医生,也很难将早期黑色素瘤与黑素细胞痣区分开来。尽管许多人认为连续数字皮肤镜检查是监测高危患者的金标准,但较差的依从性可能会严重影响其效果。2014 年,一家私人诊所报告的依从率仅为 25%,令人担忧。目前有关依从性的决定因素以及高危患者的返回率是否可接受的信息有限。
我们旨在确定我们学术机构色素病变诊所的依从率,并确定可能影响依从性的人口统计学变量。
对 120 名患者的病历进行了回顾性分析。
总体依从率为 87.5%,其中 63.3%的患者在推荐间隔内 1 个月内返回。最显著的不依从风险因素是 20 至 29 岁的患者年龄。促进依从性的因素包括黑色素瘤个人病史、大于 5 个连续监测的痣和不典型痣的个人病史。
外部有效性有限,样本量较小。
这些发现与连续监测依从性差的担忧相矛盾,并表明依从性对于风险最高的患者最高。