Becker Debbie L, Chit Ayman, DiazGranados Carlos A, Maschio Michael, Yau Eddy, Drummond Michael
a Optum , Burlington, Ontario , Canada.
b Sanofi Pasteur , Swiftwater , PA , USA.
Hum Vaccin Immunother. 2016 Dec;12(12):3036-3042. doi: 10.1080/21645515.2016.1215395. Epub 2016 Sep 26.
Seasonal influenza infects approximately 10-20% of Canadians each year, causing an estimated 12,200 hospitalizations and 3,500 deaths annually, mostly occurring in adults ≥65 years old (seniors). A 32,000-participant, randomized controlled clinical trial (FIM12; Clinicaltrials.gov NCT01427309) showed that high-dose inactivated influenza vaccine (IIV-HD) is superior to standard-dose vaccine (SD) in preventing laboratory-confirmed influenza illness in seniors. In this study, we performed a cost-utility analysis (CUA) of IIV-HD versus SD in FIM12 participants from a Canadian perspective. Healthcare resource utilization data collected in FIM12 included: medications, non-routine/urgent care and emergency room visits, and hospitalizations. Unit costs were applied using standard Canadian cost sources to estimate the mean direct medical and societal costs associated with each vaccine (2014 CAD). Clinical illness data from the trial were mapped to quality-of-life data from the literature to estimate differences in effectiveness between vaccines. Time horizon was one influenza season, however, quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) lost due to death during the study were captured over a lifetime. A probabilistic sensitivity analysis (PSA) was also performed. Average per-participant medical costs were $47 lower and societal costs $60 lower in the IIV-HD arm. Hospitalizations contributed 91% of the total cost and were less frequent in the IIV-HD arm. IIV-HD provided a gain in QALYs and, due to cost savings, dominated SD in the CUA. The PSA indicated that IIV-HD is 89% likely to be cost saving. In Canada, IIV-HD is expected to be a less costly and more effective alternative to SD, driven by a reduction in hospitalizations.
季节性流感每年感染约10%至20%的加拿大人,估计每年导致12200人住院和3500人死亡,其中大多数发生在65岁及以上的成年人(老年人)中。一项有32000名参与者的随机对照临床试验(FIM12;Clinicaltrials.gov标识符:NCT01427309)表明,高剂量灭活流感疫苗(IIV-HD)在预防老年人实验室确诊的流感疾病方面优于标准剂量疫苗(SD)。在本研究中,我们从加拿大的角度对FIM12参与者中IIV-HD与SD进行了成本效用分析(CUA)。FIM12中收集的医疗资源利用数据包括:药物、非常规/紧急护理和急诊室就诊以及住院情况。使用加拿大标准成本来源应用单位成本,以估计与每种疫苗相关的平均直接医疗和社会成本(2014年加元)。试验中的临床疾病数据与文献中的生活质量数据进行映射,以估计疫苗之间有效性的差异。时间范围为一个流感季节,然而,研究期间因死亡而损失的质量调整生命年(QALY)在一生中进行统计。还进行了概率敏感性分析(PSA)。IIV-HD组每位参与者的平均医疗成本低47加元,社会成本低60加元。住院费用占总成本的91%,且在IIV-HD组中住院频率较低。IIV-HD在QALY方面有所增加,并且由于成本节约,在CUA中优于SD。PSA表明IIV-HD有89%的可能性节省成本。在加拿大,由于住院人数减少,预计IIV-HD将成为比SD成本更低且更有效的替代方案。