Brady Catherina, Moss Hilary, Kelly Brendan D
Acute Service, St Loman's, Tallaght Hospital, Dublin, Ireland.
Irish World Academy of Music and Dance, University of Limerick, Limerick, Ireland.
Med Humanit. 2017 Mar;43(1):30-34. doi: 10.1136/medhum-2016-011040. Epub 2016 Sep 26.
Art therapy has a long history in mental healthcare, but requires an enhanced evidence base in order to better identify its precise role in contemporary services. This paper describes an evaluation of an art therapy programme in an acute adult psychiatry admission unit in Ireland. A mixed method research design was used. Quantitative data were collected through a survey of 35 staff members and 11 service users. Qualitative data included free text comments collected in the survey and individual feedback from service users. Both methods aimed to assess the role of art therapy as part of a multidisciplinary mental health service. Thematic content analysis was employed to analyse qualitative data. Staff demonstrated overwhelming support for art therapy as one element within multidisciplinary services available to patients in the acute psychiatry setting, Qualitative feedback associated art therapy with improvements in quality of life and individual support, and emphasised its role as a non-verbal intervention, especially useful for those who find talking therapy difficult. Creative self-expression is valued by staff and service users as part of the recovery process. Recommendations arising from the research include continuing the art therapy service, expanding it to include patients under rehabilitation, provision of information and education sessions to staff, and further research to identify other potential long-term effects. The low response of staff and small sample in this study, however, must be noted as limitations to these findings.
艺术疗法在精神卫生保健领域有着悠久的历史,但需要有更强有力的证据基础,以便更好地确定其在当代服务中的确切作用。本文描述了对爱尔兰一家成人急性精神病住院单元的艺术疗法项目的评估。采用了混合方法研究设计。通过对35名工作人员和11名服务使用者的调查收集定量数据。定性数据包括调查中收集的自由文本评论以及服务使用者的个人反馈。两种方法都旨在评估艺术疗法作为多学科精神卫生服务一部分的作用。采用主题内容分析法对定性数据进行分析。工作人员对艺术疗法作为急性精神病环境中患者可获得的多学科服务的一个组成部分表现出压倒性的支持。定性反馈将艺术疗法与生活质量的改善和个人支持联系起来,并强调其作为一种非语言干预的作用,对那些觉得谈话疗法困难的人特别有用。创造性的自我表达被工作人员和服务使用者视为康复过程的一部分而受到重视。该研究提出的建议包括继续开展艺术疗法服务,将其扩展到包括康复期患者,为工作人员提供信息和教育课程,以及进一步研究以确定其他潜在的长期影响。然而,必须指出,本研究中工作人员的低回复率和小样本是这些研究结果的局限性。