1 Mental Health Service, Ralph H. Johnson Veterans Affairs Medical Center, USA.
2 Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Medical University of South Carolina, USA.
J Telemed Telecare. 2018 Jan;24(1):51-55. doi: 10.1177/1357633X16671096. Epub 2016 Sep 26.
Introduction Although there is growing support that evidence-based psychotherapies (EBPs) delivered in-person and through telehealth are equivalent in terms of symptom reduction for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), there has been far less investigation comparing these treatment modalities in terms of patient satisfaction. The present study investigated participant satisfaction and perception of the quality of service delivery within a clinical trial comparing the delivery of an EBP, Prolonged Exposure (PE) for PTSD, through home-based telehealth and in-person services. Methods Veterans ( N = 67) with PTSD were randomized to receive PE via video telehealth technology ( n = 27) or via in-person delivery ( n = 40). Participants completed service demographic questions, PTSD symptom assessments, and satisfaction and service delivery perception questionnaires. Results Analyses of covariance were used to investigate the influence of treatment modality on patient satisfaction and perceived quality of service delivery, while controlling for demographics and PTSD symptoms. No differences were observed on the majority of measures, with the exception of participants in the telehealth condition endorsing willingness to drive further for telehealth services as compared with participants in the in-person condition. Discussion Findings illustrate participant satisfaction and acceptance of EBPs delivered via telehealth at a level consistent with that of in-person services. Preliminary findings suggest that the experience of receiving telehealth services may be associated with increased willingness to participate in telehealth services again. Together, these findings of patient satisfaction and acceptance of telehealth services support the ongoing delivery of EBPs via telehealth as well as their future expansion.
简介
尽管越来越多的证据表明,面对面和远程医疗提供的基于证据的心理疗法(EBPs)在减少创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)症状方面是等效的,但在患者满意度方面,对这些治疗方式的比较研究要少得多。本研究在一项临床试验中比较了基于证据的心理疗法(Prolonged Exposure,PE)在治疗 PTSD 方面的应用,该试验通过家庭远程医疗和面对面服务来进行,调查了参与者的满意度和对服务提供质量的感知。
方法
PTSD 患者(N=67)被随机分配接受视频远程医疗技术(n=27)或面对面服务(n=40)的 PE。参与者完成了服务人口统计问题、PTSD 症状评估以及满意度和服务提供感知问卷。
结果
使用协方差分析来研究治疗方式对患者满意度和感知服务提供质量的影响,同时控制人口统计学和 PTSD 症状。除了远程医疗条件下的参与者表示愿意为远程医疗服务而开车更远,而面对面条件下的参与者表示愿意为面对面服务而开车更远之外,大多数措施上没有观察到差异。
讨论
研究结果表明,远程医疗提供的 EBPs 得到了参与者的满意度和接受程度,与面对面服务相当。初步研究结果表明,接受远程医疗服务的体验可能与再次参与远程医疗服务的意愿增加有关。这些患者对远程医疗服务的满意度和接受度的研究结果支持了通过远程医疗继续提供 EBPs,以及它们的未来扩展。