PET Center, Huashan Hospital, Fudan University, Shanghai, China.
Dept. Nuclear Medicine, Technische Universität München, Munich, Germany.
Neuroimage. 2017 Feb 1;146:589-599. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2016.09.031. Epub 2016 Sep 28.
In brain F-FDG PET data intensity normalization is usually applied to control for unwanted factors confounding brain metabolism. However, it can be difficult to determine a proper intensity normalization region as a reference for the identification of abnormal metabolism in diseased brains. In neurodegenerative disorders, differentiating disease-related changes in brain metabolism from age-associated natural changes remains challenging. This study proposes a new data-driven method to identify proper intensity normalization regions in order to improve separation of age-associated natural changes from disease related changes in brain metabolism.
127 female and 128 male healthy subjects (age: 20 to 79) with brainF-FDG PET/CT in the course of a whole body cancer screening were included. Brain PET images were processed using SPM8 and were parcellated into 116 anatomical regions according to the AAL template. It is assumed that normal brain F-FDG metabolism has longitudinal coherency and this coherency leads to better model fitting. The coefficient of determination R was proposed as the coherence coefficient, and the total coherence coefficient (overall fitting quality) was employed as an index to assess proper intensity normalization strategies on single subjects and age-cohort averaged data. Age-associated longitudinal changes of normal subjects were derived using the identified intensity normalization method correspondingly. In addition, 15 subjects with clinically diagnosed Parkinson's disease were assessed to evaluate the clinical potential of the proposed new method.
Intensity normalizations by paracentral lobule and cerebellar tonsil, both regions derived from the new data-driven coherency method, showed significantly better coherence coefficients than other intensity normalization regions, and especially better than the most widely used global mean normalization. Intensity normalization by paracentral lobule was the most consistent method within both analysis strategies (subject-based and age-cohort averaging). In addition, the proposed new intensity normalization method using the paracentral lobule generates significantly higher differentiation from the age-associated changes than other intensity normalization methods.
Proper intensity normalization can enhance the longitudinal coherency of normal brain glucose metabolism. The paracentral lobule followed by the cerebellar tonsil are shown to be the two most stable intensity normalization regions concerning age-dependent brain metabolism. This may provide the potential to better differentiate disease-related changes from age-related changes in brain metabolism, which is of relevance in the diagnosis of neurodegenerative disorders.
在脑部 F-FDG PET 数据中,强度归一化通常用于控制混淆脑代谢的无关因素。然而,确定适当的强度归一化区域作为识别患病大脑中异常代谢的参考可能具有挑战性。在神经退行性疾病中,区分脑代谢与年龄相关的自然变化仍然具有挑战性。本研究提出了一种新的数据驱动方法来识别适当的强度归一化区域,以提高脑代谢中与年龄相关的自然变化与疾病相关变化的分离。
纳入了 127 名女性和 128 名男性健康受试者(年龄:20 至 79 岁),他们在全身癌症筛查期间接受了脑部 F-FDG PET/CT 检查。脑部 PET 图像使用 SPM8 进行处理,并根据 AAL 模板分为 116 个解剖区域。假设正常的脑 F-FDG 代谢具有纵向一致性,这种一致性导致更好的模型拟合。决定系数 R 被提议作为一致性系数,总一致性系数(整体拟合质量)被用作评估单一受试者和年龄队列平均数据的适当强度归一化策略的指标。相应地,使用所识别的强度归一化方法得出正常受试者的年龄相关纵向变化。此外,评估了 15 名临床诊断为帕金森病的患者,以评估所提出的新方法的临床潜力。
使用新的数据驱动一致性方法得到的旁中央小叶和小脑扁桃体的强度归一化,其一致性系数明显优于其他强度归一化区域,尤其是优于最广泛使用的全局均值归一化。在基于个体的分析策略和年龄队列平均分析策略中,旁中央小叶的强度归一化是最一致的方法。此外,与其他强度归一化方法相比,使用旁中央小叶的新的强度归一化方法可以更显著地从年龄相关变化中产生差异。
适当的强度归一化可以增强正常脑葡萄糖代谢的纵向一致性。旁中央小叶和小脑扁桃体是与年龄相关的脑代谢最稳定的两个强度归一化区域。这可能提供了从脑代谢中更好地区分与疾病相关的变化与与年龄相关的变化的潜力,这对于神经退行性疾病的诊断具有重要意义。