Maphisa David H, Smit-Robinson Hanneline, Underhill Les G, Altwegg Res
South African National Biodiversity Institute, Private Bag X7, Claremont 7735, South Africa.
Statistics in Ecology, Environment and Conservation, Department of Statistical Sciences University of Cape Town, Rondebosch 7701, South Africa.
PLoS One. 2016 Oct 5;11(10):e0162609. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0162609. eCollection 2016.
Moist high-altitude grasslands in South Africa are renowned for high avifaunal diversity and are priority areas for conservation. Conservation management of these areas conflicts with management for other uses, such as intensive livestock agriculture, which requires annual burning and leads to heavy grazing. Recently the area has become target for water storage schemes and renewable electricity energy projects. There is therefore an urgent need to investigate environmental factors and habitat factors that affect bird species richness in order to optimise management of those areas set aside for conservation. A particularly good opportunity to study these issues arose at Ingula in the eastern South African high-altitude grasslands. An area that had been subject to intense grazing was bought by the national power utility that constructed a pumped storage scheme on part of the land and set aside the rest for bird conservation. Since the new management took over in 2005 the area has been mostly annually burned with relatively little grazing. The new management seeks scientific advice on how to maintain avian species richness of the study area. We collected bird occurrence and vegetation data along random transects between 2006 and 2010 to monitor the impact of the new management, and to study the effect of the habitat changes on bird species richness. To achieve these, we convert bird transect data to presence only data to investigate how bird species richness were related to key transect vegetation attributes under this new grassland management. First we used generalised linear mixed models, to examine changes in vegetation grass height and cover and between burned and unburned habitats. Secondly, we examined how total bird species richness varied across seasons and years. And finally we investigated which habitat vegetation attributes were correlated with species richness of a group of grassland depended bird species only. Transects that were burned showed a larger decrease in vegetation cover compared to transects that were not burned. Grass height increased over time. Bird species richness was highest in summer compared to other seasons and increased over time. Overall bird species richness increased over the three summer surveys but species richness of birds that prefer heavily grazed habitat showed little change over the three years. Changes in bird species richness were best explained by the model with grass height for combined species richness of grassland depended birds but also for birds that prefer heavy grazing when treated alone. On one hand birds that prefer moderate grazing were best explained by a null model. However, overall bird species richness was better positively correlated to grass height than grass cover or dead grass. We conclude that frequent burning alone with relatively reduced grazing led to higher but less dense grass, which benefited some species and disadvantaged others. We suggest that management of this grassland use combination of fire and grazing and leave some areas unburned to accommodates birds of various habitat needs.
南非湿润的高海拔草原以鸟类多样性高而闻名,是重点保护区域。这些区域的保护管理与其他用途的管理存在冲突,比如集约化畜牧业,这种畜牧业需要每年焚烧草地并导致过度放牧。最近,该地区成为蓄水计划和可再生电力能源项目的目标。因此,迫切需要调查影响鸟类物种丰富度的环境因素和栖息地因素,以便优化那些预留作保护用途区域的管理。在南非东部高海拔草原的英古拉出现了一个研究这些问题的绝佳机会。一个曾遭受过度放牧的区域被国家电力公司买下,该公司在部分土地上建设了抽水蓄能计划,并将其余部分留作鸟类保护用地。自2005年新的管理措施实施以来,该区域大多每年进行焚烧,放牧相对较少。新的管理方寻求关于如何维持研究区域鸟类物种丰富度的科学建议。我们在2006年至2010年间沿着随机样带收集鸟类出现情况和植被数据,以监测新管理措施的影响,并研究栖息地变化对鸟类物种丰富度的作用。为实现这些目标,我们将鸟类样带数据转换为仅存在数据,以研究在这种新的草原管理方式下鸟类物种丰富度与关键样带植被属性之间的关系。首先,我们使用广义线性混合模型,来检验植被草高和覆盖度在焚烧和未焚烧栖息地之间的变化。其次,我们研究了鸟类物种总丰富度在不同季节和年份的变化情况。最后,我们调查了哪些栖息地植被属性仅与一组依赖草原的鸟类物种丰富度相关。与未焚烧的样带相比,焚烧过的样带植被覆盖度下降幅度更大。草高随时间增加。与其他季节相比,夏季鸟类物种丰富度最高,且随时间增加。在三次夏季调查中,鸟类物种总丰富度总体上有所增加,但偏好重度放牧栖息地的鸟类物种丰富度在三年间变化不大。对于依赖草原的鸟类物种以及单独考虑时偏好重度放牧的鸟类物种的综合物种丰富度而言,草高对鸟类物种丰富度变化的解释最为充分。一方面对于偏好适度放牧的鸟类,空模型的解释最为恰当。然而,总体鸟类物种丰富度与草高的正相关性比与草覆盖度或枯草的相关性更好。我们得出结论,频繁焚烧且放牧相对减少导致草更高但密度更低,这对一些物种有利而对另一些物种不利。我们建议,对这片草原的管理应结合火灾和放牧,并留出一些区域不进行焚烧,以满足各种栖息地需求的鸟类生存。