Ushio Masahiro, Egi Moritoki, Wakabayashi Junji, Nishimura Taichi, Miyatake Yuji, Obata Norihiko, Mizobuchi Satoshi
Department of Anesthesia, Kakogawa West City Hospital, Kakogawa City, Hyogo, Japan.
Department of Anesthesiology, Kobe University Hospital, Kobe City, Hyogo, Japan.
J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth. 2016 Dec;30(6):1454-1460. doi: 10.1053/j.jvca.2016.07.027. Epub 2016 Jul 21.
To determine the effects of milrinone on short-term mortality in cardiac surgery patients with focus on the presence or absence of heterogeneity of the effect.
A systematic review and meta-analysis.
Five hundred thirty-seven adult cardiac surgery patients from 12 RCTs.
Milrinone administration.
The authors conducted a systematic Medline and Pubmed search to assess the effect of milrinone on short-term mortality in adult cardiac surgery patients. Subanalysis was performed according to the timing for commencement of milrinone administration and the type of comparators. The primary outcome was any short-term mortality. Overall analysis showed no difference in mortality rates in patients who received milrinone and patients who received comparators (odds ratio = 1.25, 95% CI 0.45-3.51, p = 0.67). In subanalysis for the timing to commence milrinone administration and the type of comparators, odds ratio for mortality varied from 0.19 (placebo as control drug, start of administration after cardiopulmonary bypass) to 2.58 (levosimendan as control drug, start of administration after cardiopulmonary bypass).
Among RCTs to assess the effect of milrinone administration in adult cardiac surgery patients, there are wide variations of the odds ratios of administration of milrinone for short-term mortality according to the comparators and the timing of administration. This fact may suggest that a simple pooling meta-analysis is not applicable for assessing the risk and benefit of milrinone administration in an adult cardiac surgery cohort.
确定米力农对心脏手术患者短期死亡率的影响,并重点关注效应的异质性是否存在。
系统评价和荟萃分析。
来自12项随机对照试验的537例成年心脏手术患者。
使用米力农。
作者对Medline和Pubmed进行了系统检索,以评估米力农对成年心脏手术患者短期死亡率的影响。根据米力农给药开始时间和对照类型进行亚组分析。主要结局为任何短期死亡率。总体分析显示,接受米力农的患者与接受对照的患者死亡率无差异(比值比 = 1.25,95%可信区间0.45 - 3.51,p = 0.67)。在米力农给药开始时间和对照类型的亚组分析中,死亡率的比值比从0.19(以安慰剂作为对照药物,体外循环后开始给药)到2.58(以左西孟旦作为对照药物,体外循环后开始给药)不等。
在评估米力农对成年心脏手术患者影响的随机对照试验中,根据对照和给药时间不同,米力农给药用于短期死亡率的比值比存在很大差异。这一事实可能表明,简单的合并荟萃分析不适用于评估成年心脏手术队列中米力农给药的风险和益处。