Shea M K, Gilhooly C H, Dawson-Hughes B
Bone Metabolism Laboratory, USDA Human Nutrition Research Center on Aging, Tufts University, Boston, MA, USA.
Eur J Clin Nutr. 2017 Mar;71(3):420-424. doi: 10.1038/ejcn.2016.195. Epub 2016 Oct 19.
BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES: Acid-producing diets have been associated with adverse health conditions. Dietary acid load can be estimated from dietary intake data, but the available methods require a full dietary assessment. We sought to identify a simpler means to estimate 24-h urinary net acid excretion (NAE), a robust measure of net endogenous acid production, using self-reported intakes of fruits, vegetables (acid-neutralizing foods), grain and/or protein (acid-producing foods) acquired by two different methods in community-dwelling older adults. Identifying food groups associated with NAE by using a method not requiring a full diet assessment could have a broad clinical application.
SUBJECTS/METHODS: Fruit, vegetable, protein and grain servings/day were estimated with a widely used food frequency questionnaire (study A, n=162, 63±8 years). Differences in their intakes across NAE categories (<5, ⩾5 to <15, ⩾15 to <50, ⩾50 milliequivalents (mEq)/day) were analyzed using analysis of variance. The findings were verified in a second study, which estimated dietary intakes, using a more detailed record-assisted 24-h recall (study B, n=232, 67±6 years).
Fruit intake was significantly associated with NAE in both studies. In study A, fruit intake was 9% lower with each categorical NAE increase (unstandardized beta=-0.21, P=0.01) and 7% lower with each categorical NAE increase in study B (unstandardized beta=-0.18; P=0.02). Grain intake was positively associated with NAE in study B only (unstandardized beta=+0.14; P=0.01). Vegetable and protein intake were not associated with NAE in either study.
The inverse association between fruit intake and NAE suggests low self-reported fruit intake may be an indicator of acid-producing diets in older adults.
背景/目的:产酸饮食与不良健康状况相关。膳食酸负荷可根据膳食摄入数据估算,但现有方法需要进行全面的膳食评估。我们试图找到一种更简便的方法,通过社区居住的老年人采用两种不同方法获取的水果、蔬菜(酸碱中和食物)、谷物和/或蛋白质(产酸食物)的自我报告摄入量,来估算24小时尿净酸排泄量(NAE),这是衡量内源性酸产生净值的可靠指标。通过一种无需全面膳食评估的方法来确定与NAE相关的食物组可能具有广泛的临床应用价值。
对象/方法:使用广泛应用的食物频率问卷估算每日水果、蔬菜、蛋白质和谷物的摄入量(研究A,n = 162,63±8岁)。使用方差分析分析不同NAE类别(<5、≥5至<15、≥15至<50、≥50毫当量(mEq)/天)的摄入量差异。在第二项研究中验证了研究结果,该研究使用更详细的记录辅助24小时回忆法估算膳食摄入量(研究B,n = 232,67±6岁)。
两项研究中水果摄入量均与NAE显著相关。在研究A中,随着NAE每增加一个类别,水果摄入量降低9%(非标准化β=-0.21,P = 0.01);在研究B中,随着NAE每增加一个类别,水果摄入量降低7%(非标准化β=-0.18;P = 0.02)。仅在研究B中谷物摄入量与NAE呈正相关(非标准化β=+0.14;P = 0.01)。两项研究中蔬菜和蛋白质摄入量均与NAE无关。
水果摄入量与NAE之间的负相关表明,自我报告的水果摄入量较低可能是老年人产酸饮食的一个指标。