Yanagihara Kiyotaka, Kinugasa Yoshiharu, Shirota Kinya, Inoue Yoshiaki, Ishii Hiroshige, Tsunoda Fumiyo, Iwata Masaaki, Sugihara Shinobu, Takeda Shinya, Hirai Masayuki, Mimura Asao, Kato Masahiko, Yamamoto Kazuhiro
Department of Cardiovascular Medicine Matsue Red Cross Hospital Matsue Japan.
Division of Cardiovascular Medicine, Department of Molecular Medicine and Therapeutics, Faculty of Medicine Tottori University Yonago Japan.
ESC Heart Fail. 2016 Mar;3(1):18-25. doi: 10.1002/ehf2.12060. Epub 2015 Sep 24.
Inadequate self-care management is a leading cause of re-hospitalization in patients with heart failure (HF). Psychological factors such as some ego functions interfere with self-care behaviour modification, leading to poor outcomes in patients with several chronic diseases. However, characteristics of ego states in patients with repeated hospitalization for HF remain undefined.
The present study enrolled 40 HF outpatients with previous history of HF hospitalization and receiving self-care management. Patients' psychological characteristics were assessed by Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) for screening depressive symptoms, and the Tokyo University Egogram (TEG) New Version II for analysing human behaviour based on five functional ego states; critical parent, nurturing parent, adult, free child, and adapted child (AC). Twelve patients (30.0%) had previous history of repeated (two or more) HF hospitalization. Most of them (75%) had a history of at least one or more re-hospitalizations related to inadequate self-care. Patients with repeated HF hospitalization had significantly lower AC score, which represents uncooperative and uncompromising behaviours, compared with those without repeated HF hospitalization ( < 0.05). There were no significant differences in other parameters, including PHQ-9, between the two groups.
Low AC ego state was associated with high prevalence of repeated hospitalization in patients with HF. Assessing ego functions may be helpful to tailor educational approaches in these patients.
自我护理管理不足是心力衰竭(HF)患者再次住院的主要原因。一些自我功能等心理因素会干扰自我护理行为的改变,导致多种慢性病患者预后不良。然而,因HF反复住院患者的自我状态特征仍不明确。
本研究纳入了40名有HF住院史且正在接受自我护理管理的HF门诊患者。通过患者健康问卷(PHQ - 9)评估患者的心理特征以筛查抑郁症状,并使用东京大学自我状态图(TEG)第二版基于五个功能性自我状态分析人类行为;批评性父母、养育性父母、成人、自由儿童和适应儿童(AC)。12名患者(30.0%)有HF反复(两次或更多次)住院史。其中大多数(75%)有至少一次或更多次与自我护理不足相关的再住院史。与无HF反复住院的患者相比,HF反复住院的患者AC得分显著更低,AC得分代表不合作和不妥协行为(<0.05)。两组之间在包括PHQ - 9在内的其他参数上无显著差异。
低AC自我状态与HF患者反复住院的高患病率相关。评估自我功能可能有助于为这些患者量身定制教育方法。