Thomas Debi M, Wieck Minna M, Grant Christa N, Dossa Avafia, Nowicki Donna, Stanley Phillip, Zeinati Chadi, Howell Lori K, Anselmo Dean M
Departments of Pediatric Surgery, Children's Hospital Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California.
Departments of Pediatric Surgery, Children's Hospital Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California.
J Vasc Interv Radiol. 2016 Dec;27(12):1846-1856. doi: 10.1016/j.jvir.2016.08.012. Epub 2016 Oct 22.
To evaluate efficacy of sclerotherapy with doxycycline versus sodium tetradecyl sulfate (STS) for treatment of macrocystic and mixed lymphatic malformations (LMs).
This single-center retrospective review identified 41 children (17 boys; 24 girls; age range, 1 month to 15.4 y) who underwent sclerotherapy with doxycycline (n = 32) or STS (n = 9) for macrocystic (n = 31) or mixed (n = 10) LMs. There were 114 treatments performed, averaging 2.8 treatments (range, 1-8 treatments) per patient. Average follow-up time was 10 months (range, 1-59 months). Clinical response was deemed excellent or moderate if > 90% or > 50% of LMs resolved based on visual estimate.
With doxycycline, 87% of patients (28 of 32) had excellent or moderate response with an average of 2.8 treatments (range, 1-7 treatments); 13% required subsequent resection. With 3% STS monotherapy, only 55% of patients (5 of 9) had excellent or moderate response with an average of 2.8 treatments (range, 1-8 treatments), and 33% required subsequent resection. Significantly fewer patients treated with STS responded well compared with patients treated with doxycycline (P = .03). Patients treated with STS had significantly longer follow-up than patients treated with doxycycline (27 months vs 6 months, P = .0001).
Doxycycline monotherapy resulted in a high rate of excellent clinical outcomes after a few treatments without increased need for subsequent operative resection. These results support use of doxycycline sclerotherapy as primary treatment for macrocystic and mixed LMs in children.
评估强力霉素与十四烷基硫酸钠(STS)硬化治疗对大囊型和混合型淋巴管畸形(LM)的疗效。
这项单中心回顾性研究纳入了41例接受强力霉素(n = 32)或STS(n = 9)硬化治疗的大囊型(n = 31)或混合型(n = 10)LM患儿(17例男孩;24例女孩;年龄范围1个月至15.4岁)。共进行了114次治疗,每位患者平均接受2.8次治疗(范围1 - 8次治疗)。平均随访时间为10个月(范围1 - 59个月)。根据视觉估计,如果超过90%或超过50%的LM消退,则临床反应被视为优或良。
使用强力霉素治疗时,87%的患者(32例中的28例)获得优或良的反应,平均接受2.8次治疗(范围1 - 7次治疗);13%的患者需要后续手术切除。STS单药治疗时,仅55%的患者(9例中的5例)获得优或良的反应,平均接受2.8次治疗(范围1 - 8次治疗),33%的患者需要后续手术切除。与强力霉素治疗的患者相比,接受STS治疗且反应良好的患者明显更少(P = 0.03)。接受STS治疗的患者随访时间明显长于接受强力霉素治疗的患者(27个月对6个月;P = 0.0001)。
强力霉素单药治疗经过几次治疗后可产生较高比例的优临床结局,且无需增加后续手术切除的需求。这些结果支持将强力霉素硬化治疗作为儿童大囊型和混合型LM的主要治疗方法。