Hickey Michelle J, Zheng Ying, Valenzuela Nicole, Zhang Qiuheng, Krystal Carolyn, Lum Erik, Tsai Eileen W, Lipshutz Gerald S, Gritsch H Albin, Danovitch Gabriel, Veale Jeffrey, Gjertson David, Cecka Michael, Reed Elaine F
UCLA Immunogenetics Center, Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, University of California, Los Angeles, CA, USA.
UCLA Immunogenetics Center, Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, University of California, Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Hum Immunol. 2017 Jan;78(1):41-48. doi: 10.1016/j.humimm.2016.10.020. Epub 2016 Nov 3.
UNOS implemented a new Kidney Allocation System (New KAS) on December 4, 2014 with a primary goal of increasing equity to organ transplant for patients that were immunologically or socially disadvantaged by the previous allocation system (Previous KAS) that prioritized long wait times. We examined the effects of the New KAS on patients transplanted from the UCLA deceased donor waitlist during the first year and compared to the last year of the Previous KAS. The total number of deceased donor kidney transplants was increased in the New KAS as compared to the Previous KAS (178 vs 148). Transplant of regraft patients and of highly sensitized patients with cPRA⩾99% was significantly increased in the New KAS (New KAS vs Previous KAS, 29.8% vs 11.5%, p⩽0.0001, and 26.4% vs 2.7%, p⩽0.0001, respectively). In the New KAS, the percentage of patient's receiving allografts imported from outside our local area was also significantly increased (34.8% vs 15.5%, p<0.0001). In the New KAS, 59.7% and 48.3% of imported organs were allocated to very highly sensitized (⩾99% cPRA) or re-graft patients, respectively, as compared to 8.7% and 8.7% during the Previous KAS (p<0.001). Recipients and donors with age differences exceeding 15years were decreased in the New KAS as compared to the Previous KAS (36.5 vs 48.7%, p⩽0.032). There was a 40.1% reduction in transplant to patients in the 65+ age group in the New KAS (p⩽0.025). The percentage of patients transplanted with preformed donor specific antibody (DSA) was similar in the New as compared to the Previous KAS (19.7% vs 15.5%) and, patients were transplanted with a range of 1-3 preformed DSA of weak to moderate strength. Cold ischemic time was significantly increased over all organs, and in patients transplanted with preformed DSA during the New as compared to the Previous KAS (17.5 vs 19.1h and 17.2 vs 22.2, p<0.04 and p<0.03, respectively). Episodes of delayed graft function and the number of biopsies for cause were similar between the New and the Previous KAS. However, there were more events of biopsy proven antibody mediated rejection in patients transplanted since the start of the New KAS. The data show that the New KAS is working at the center level as designed to better age match recipients and donors and to increase transplantation of very highly sensitized patients through broader sharing.
2014年12月4日,器官共享联合网络(UNOS)实施了新的肾脏分配系统(New KAS),其主要目标是提高那些因先前优先考虑长时间等待的分配系统(Previous KAS)而在免疫或社会方面处于不利地位的患者获得器官移植的公平性。我们研究了New KAS对第一年从加州大学洛杉矶分校已故捐赠者等待名单上接受移植的患者的影响,并与Previous KAS的最后一年进行了比较。与Previous KAS相比,New KAS中已故捐赠者肾脏移植的总数有所增加(178例对148例)。New KAS中再次移植患者和群体反应性抗体(cPRA)≥99%的高敏患者的移植显著增加(New KAS与Previous KAS相比,分别为29.8%对11.5%,p≤0.0001,以及26.4%对2.7%,p≤0.0001)。在New KAS中,接受从本地以外地区进口的同种异体移植物的患者百分比也显著增加(34.8%对15.5%,p<0.0001)。在New KAS中,分别有59.7%和48.3%的进口器官分配给了非常高敏(cPRA≥99%)或再次移植患者,而在Previous KAS期间这一比例为8.7%和8.7%(p<0.001)。与Previous KAS相比,New KAS中年龄差异超过15岁的受者和捐赠者减少了(36.5%对48.7%,p≤0.032)。New KAS中65岁及以上年龄组患者的移植减少了40.1%(p≤0.025)。与Previous KAS相比,New KAS中移植时带有预先形成的供者特异性抗体(DSA)的患者百分比相似(19.7%对15.5%),并且患者移植时带有1 - 3种强度从弱到中等的预先形成的DSA。所有器官的冷缺血时间显著增加,并且与Previous KAS相比,New KAS期间移植时带有预先形成的DSA的患者的冷缺血时间也增加(17.5对19.1小时以及17.2对22.2小时,分别为p<0.04和p<0.03)。New KAS和Previous KAS之间移植肾功能延迟发作的次数和因病因进行活检的次数相似。然而,自New KAS开始以来接受移植的患者中,活检证实的抗体介导排斥事件更多。数据表明,New KAS在中心层面按设计发挥作用,能更好地使受者和捐赠者年龄匹配,并通过更广泛的共享增加非常高敏患者的移植。