de Liefde B, Herbison G P
N Z Dent J. 1989 Jan;85(379):2-8.
Seven hundred and twenty-seven 9-year-old children resident in Hawke's Bay were examined in 1985, 3 years after a baseline survey of a cohort of the same age group. Children were allocated to one of four fluoride-history groups on the basis of the responses of parents to a questionnaire, which also gave information on infant feeding and household water source. Examination conditions were duplicated, and children were examined by the same examiner using a modification of the DDE Index. The prevalence of diffuse defects in the low fluoride (LF) group (24.3 percent) was lower (P less than 0.001) than in the fluoridated water (WF) group (50.8 percent), the PT group who had used tablets to 5 to 6 years of age (53.1 percent), and the CT group who had used tablets continuously (54.7 percent). There were 2.9 percent of children with contralateral pairs of teeth with diffuse opacities in the LF group compared with 22.9 percent in the WF group, 18.7 percent in the PT group, and 36.0 percent in the CT group. For European children, 9.7 percent had post-eruptive defect sub-types. Defect prevalence could not be related to infant feeding or water source in unfluoridated areas. There had been a significant increase in the prevalence of diffuse defects in the WF, PT, and CT groups, but not the LF group since the baseline survey. There was also an increase in the numbers of children considered to have an unsatisfactory appearance due to either continuous or diffuse opacities--from none in 1982, to 24 (3.7 percent) in 1985. In the 3 years since the baseline survey there had been considerable reductions in the caries prevalence in all groups (P less than 0.001).
1985年,对居住在霍克湾的727名9岁儿童进行了检查,这是对同一年龄组队列进行基线调查3年后的检查。根据家长对一份问卷的回答,将儿童分为四个氟化物接触史组,问卷还提供了婴儿喂养和家庭水源的信息。检查条件与之前相同,由同一名检查人员使用改良的DDE指数对儿童进行检查。低氟(LF)组的弥漫性缺损患病率(24.3%)低于(P<0.001)氟化水(WF)组(50.8%)、5至6岁使用片剂的PT组(53.1%)和持续使用片剂的CT组(54.7%)。LF组有2.9%的儿童对侧牙齿有弥漫性混浊,而WF组为22.9%,PT组为18.7%,CT组为36.0%。对于欧洲儿童,9.7%有萌出后缺损亚型。在未氟化地区,缺损患病率与婴儿喂养或水源无关。自基线调查以来,WF、PT和CT组的弥漫性缺损患病率显著增加,但LF组没有。由于持续性或弥漫性混浊而被认为外观不满意的儿童数量也有所增加——从1982年的零例增加到1985年的24例(3.7%)。自基线调查后的3年里,所有组的龋齿患病率都有相当程度的下降(P<0.001)。