Bloorview Research Institute, Holland Bloorview Kids Rehabilitation Hospital, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Dalla Lana School of Public Health and Rehabilitation Sciences Institute, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Obes Rev. 2017 Feb;18(2):164-182. doi: 10.1111/obr.12485. Epub 2016 Nov 26.
Healthcare professionals have called for direction on how best to communicate about weight-related topics with children and families. Established scoping review methodology was used to answer the question: 'How can healthcare professionals best communicate with children and their families about obesity and weight-related topics?'
We searched four scientific databases, two grey literature repositories and 14 key journals (2005-2016). Inclusion criteria were (i) children up to and including 18 years of age and/or their parents; (ii) communication about healthy weight, overweight, obesity or healthy/active living; and (iii) healthcare setting.
Thirty-two articles were included. Evidence-based best practices were largely absent from the literature, although the following guiding principles were identified: (i) include all stakeholders in discussions; (ii) raise the topic of weight and health early and regularly; (iii) use strengths-based language emphasizing health over weight; (iv) use collaborative goal-setting to engage children and parents and (v) augment discussions with appropriate tools and resources. Guidance on how to implement these principles and how to negotiate relevant contextual factors (e.g. age, culture and disability) is still needed.
Despite agreement on a number of guiding principles, evidence-based weight-related communication best practices are lacking. Rigorous, empirical evaluations of communication approaches are urgently required, especially those that include children's perspectives.
医疗保健专业人员呼吁提供有关如何与儿童和家庭就体重相关话题进行最佳沟通的指导。采用既定的范围综述方法来回答这个问题:“医疗保健专业人员如何才能最好地与儿童及其家庭就肥胖和体重相关话题进行沟通?”
我们搜索了四个科学数据库、两个灰色文献库和 14 种主要期刊(2005-2016 年)。纳入标准为:(i)年龄在 18 岁及以下的儿童和/或他们的父母;(ii)关于健康体重、超重、肥胖或健康/积极生活的沟通;(iii)医疗保健环境。
共纳入 32 篇文章。尽管确定了以下指导原则:(i)在讨论中包括所有利益相关者;(ii)尽早并定期提出体重和健康问题;(iii)使用强调健康而非体重的基于优势的语言;(iv)使用协作性目标设定来吸引儿童和家长;(v)用适当的工具和资源来补充讨论,但文献中基本上没有基于证据的最佳实践。仍然需要关于如何实施这些原则以及如何协商相关背景因素(例如年龄、文化和残疾)的指导。
尽管在一些指导原则上达成了一致,但缺乏基于证据的体重相关沟通最佳实践。迫切需要对沟通方法进行严格的、实证的评估,尤其是那些包含儿童观点的方法。