Giorgi Giovanni, Ferrarello Francesco, Merlo Francesca, Fumagalli Stefano, Marchionni Niccolò, Di Bari Mauro
Outpatient Rehabilitation Service, Fondazione Maria Assunta in Cielo Onlus, Pistoia, Italy.
Functional Rehabilitation Unit, Azienda USL Toscana Centro, Prato, Italy.
J Geriatr Phys Ther. 2018 Jul/Sep;41(3):134-142. doi: 10.1519/JPT.0000000000000113.
Action observation training (AOT) consists of the observing of actions performed by others, followed by imitation. Physical therapy techniques based on action observation may influence motor performance in individuals with idiopathic Parkinson's disease (IPD).
The aim of this pilot study was to provide a preliminary approach to assess AOT in anatomical first-person perspective (FPP) as a rehabilitation technique to improve body function and activity in individuals with disability due to IPD.
Videos showing in FPP movements of the upper and lower limbs were produced. A research protocol was designed and tested for feasibility. After baseline assessment, 16 participants with mild to moderate disability due to IPD, all receiving conventional physical therapy group treatment, were nonrandomly assigned to either 1 extra hour of individualized FPP AOT per session or comparison group. Upper and lower limb functioning, independence in activity of daily living, and mobility were assessed before and after training. Data were analyzed by descriptive statistics; statistical comparisons were conducted as part of the feasibility assessment of the data management plan by means of nonparametric tests.
A set of 22 videos was created and administered. Groups were comparable at baseline assessment. All participants completed the study and had complete data. Compared with baseline, both groups improved significantly. The experimental group had a better response based on change scores, and the differences were large for 3 of the outcome measures. No significant between-group differences were observed.
The equipment needed for the production of the videos was easily available. The study protocol was successfully implemented. Adherence rates to study procedures were excellent, and no adverse events occurred. Differences in methods and participant populations prevented comparison in our experimental approach. The number and content of videos, and the length of the sessions proposed, was close to that of other studies providing an FPP AOT program in individuals with cerebral palsy and stroke. Both groups improved and the effect was greater for the experimental one. However, no significant difference between the groups was observed.
This pilot study suggests that FPP AOT is a feasible intervention and the research protocol designed would be suitable, with minor modifications, for the conduction of a subsequent stage 2 trial designed to verify the hypothesis that the adjunct of FPP AOT might improve motor performance in individuals with IPD.
动作观察训练(AOT)包括观察他人执行的动作,随后进行模仿。基于动作观察的物理治疗技术可能会影响特发性帕金森病(IPD)患者的运动表现。
本初步研究的目的是提供一种初步方法,以解剖学第一人称视角(FPP)评估AOT作为一种康复技术,来改善因IPD导致残疾的个体的身体功能和活动能力。
制作了展示上下肢FPP运动的视频。设计并测试了一项研究方案的可行性。在基线评估后,16名因IPD导致轻度至中度残疾且均接受常规物理治疗组治疗的参与者被非随机分配到每组每次额外增加1小时个体化FPP AOT的组或对照组。在训练前后评估上下肢功能、日常生活活动独立性和移动能力。数据通过描述性统计进行分析;作为数据管理计划可行性评估的一部分,通过非参数检验进行统计比较。
创建并管理了一组22个视频。两组在基线评估时具有可比性。所有参与者均完成了研究且拥有完整数据。与基线相比,两组均有显著改善。基于变化分数,实验组有更好的反应,并且在3项结局指标上差异较大。未观察到组间显著差异。
制作视频所需的设备很容易获得。研究方案成功实施。对研究程序的依从率很高,且未发生不良事件。方法和参与者群体的差异妨碍了我们实验方法中的比较。视频的数量和内容以及提议的疗程长度与其他为脑瘫和中风个体提供FPP AOT方案的研究相近。两组均有改善,且实验组的效果更大。然而,未观察到组间显著差异。
本初步研究表明FPP AOT是一种可行的干预措施,所设计的研究方案经过微小修改后将适合用于后续的2期试验,该试验旨在验证FPP AOT辅助治疗可能改善IPD患者运动表现这一假设。