Braungart Sarah, Beattie Thomas, Midgley Paula, Powis Mark
Department of Paediatric Surgery, Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, UK; Child Life and Health, University of Edinburgh, UK.
Child Life and Health, University of Edinburgh, UK.
J Pediatr Surg. 2017 Feb;52(2):293-298. doi: 10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2016.11.028. Epub 2016 Nov 14.
No consensus exists on management of children with a negative trauma CT following blunt abdominal trauma (BAT). Asymptomatic children are frequently "admitted for observation" following negative CT owing to concerns about missing an intraabdominal injury (IAI) without evidence for this practice. We aimed to investigate the feasibility of discharge following a negative CT scan in children sustaining blunt abdominal trauma.
Retrospective audit at a UK paediatric major trauma center and review of the literature.
108 patients were included (median age 11y; 60% male). Commonest mechanisms of injury: road traffic collisions (61 patients; 56%) and falls from a height (37; 34%). 40 (37%) had a normal CT scan, of whom 6 (15%) were discharged from ED. The remaining 34 patients were admitted, of whom 14 (41%) were discharged within 24h. The other 20 children were admitted for other specialty input. None of the 108 children had a missed IAI or reattended with suspicion of IAI. The NPV for CT to detect IAI was 100% (95% CI: 96%-100%). The literature search identified 3 observational cohort studies and 2 patient groups contained in a systematic review (total of 9149 patients with normal CT abdomen after BAT). Only 9 (<0.1%) patients required operative intervention for missed IAI. The NPV for CT to detect IAI was 99.6%-99.8% (95% CI 99%-100%).
Our study and literature review demonstrate that asymptomatic children with a normal abdominal CT scan in the ED are very unlikely to have IAI and that the NPV of CT is very high (96%-100%). Direct discharge from the ED is possible for asymptomatic children with a negative CT following blunt abdominal trauma, as long as no other reasons for admission exist and should be accompanied by safety-net advice.
This is a level II evidence study. In itself it is a retrospective study, with the literature review including one large, high-quality prospective cohort study, and further prospective cohort studies of ordinary quality.
对于钝性腹部创伤(BAT)后CT检查结果为阴性的儿童的管理,目前尚无共识。由于担心漏诊腹腔内损伤(IAI)且无相关证据支持,无症状儿童在CT检查结果为阴性后常被“收住观察”。我们旨在探讨钝性腹部创伤儿童CT扫描结果为阴性后出院的可行性。
在英国一家儿科重大创伤中心进行回顾性审计并查阅文献。
纳入108例患者(中位年龄11岁;60%为男性)。最常见的致伤机制:道路交通碰撞(61例患者;56%)和高处坠落(37例;34%)。40例(37%)CT扫描正常,其中6例(15%)从急诊科出院。其余34例患者收住入院,其中14例(41%)在24小时内出院。另外20名儿童因其他专科会诊而入院。108例儿童中无一例漏诊IAI或因怀疑IAI而复诊。CT检测IAI的阴性预测值为100%(95%CI:96%-100%)。文献检索确定了3项观察性队列研究以及系统评价中包含的2个患者组(钝性腹部创伤后腹部CT正常的患者共涉及总共9149例)。只有9例(<0.1%)患者因漏诊IAI需要手术干预。CT检测IAI的阴性预测值为99.6%-99.8%(95%CI 99%-100%)。
我们的研究和文献综述表明,急诊科腹部CT扫描正常的无症状儿童发生IAI的可能性非常低,且CT的阴性预测值非常高(96%-100%)。钝性腹部创伤后CT检查结果为阴性的无症状儿童,只要没有其他入院原因,可直接从急诊科出院,并应给予安全网建议。
这是一项II级证据研究。其本身是一项回顾性研究,文献综述包括一项大型、高质量的前瞻性队列研究以及其他普通质量的前瞻性队列研究。