Frost Chelsea, Rubery Paul T, Mesfin Addisu
University of South Florida Morsani College of Medicine, 12901 Bruce B Downs Blvd, Tampa, FL 33612, USA.
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of Rochester School of Medicine and Dentistry, Rochester, NY 14642, USA.
Spine Deform. 2015 Nov;3(6):528-532. doi: 10.1016/j.jspd.2015.04.009. Epub 2015 Oct 28.
Observational Study.
To evaluate the publication rate of podium presentations from the Scoliosis Research Society (SRS) and the International Meeting of Advanced Spinal Techniques (IMAST) annuals meeting and to compare the publication rate of SRS/IMAST meetings to other orthopedic and spine meetings.
Although various publication rates from orthopedic meetings have been reported, recent publication rates from the SRS and IMAST annual meetings are not known.
Paper presentations and award-nominated papers from the 2009 to 2011 annual SRS and IMAST meetings were identified. Using PubMed, we searched for publications with a title of the paper presentations or containing the same authors. The publication rate of the award-nominated papers were evaluated in the same manner. We also identified the destination journals of the papers.
A total of 764 podium presentations were presented at SRS and IMAST from 2009 to 2011. Of these 764 abstracts, 339 were published in peer-reviewed journals, with an overall publication rate of 44.37%. The publication rates for the two different meetings (SRS and IMAST) were significantly different, 47.83% (SRS) and 41.53% (IMAST), p = .03. Award-nominated abstracts had a publication rate of 63.64% (49/77) significantly different than nonnominated abstracts, 42.4% (290/684); p = .0004. There was a significant difference in publication rates between the SRS award-nominated abstracts (72.97%, 27/37) and the nonnominated abstracts (45.25%; 138/305), p = .0001. There was no difference in publication rates for IMAST award-nominated abstracts 55% (21/40) and nonnominated abstracts (40.1%, 152/379), p = .27. The publication rate was highest for 2010 abstracts (45.78%), followed by 2009 (43.94%), and lowest for 2011 (43.43%). Spine was the most common publication journal for the two meetings.
In one of the first studies evaluating the publication rate of podium presentation from the SRS and IMAST annual meetings, we found an overall publication rate of 44.37% (47.83% SRS, 41.53% IMAST) and 63.64% for award-nominated papers.
观察性研究。
评估脊柱侧弯研究学会（SRS）和国际先进脊柱技术会议（IMAST）年会的大会发言发表率，并比较SRS/IMAST会议与其他骨科和脊柱会议的发表率。
尽管已报道了各种骨科会议的发表率，但SRS和IMAST年会最近的发表率尚不清楚。
确定2009年至2011年SRS和IMAST年会的论文报告和获提名奖的论文。使用PubMed，我们搜索了标题为论文报告或包含相同作者的出版物。以相同方式评估获提名奖论文的发表率。我们还确定了论文的发表期刊。
2009年至2011年，SRS和IMAST共进行了764次大会发言。在这764篇摘要中，339篇发表在同行评审期刊上，总体发表率为44.37%。两个不同会议（SRS和IMAST）的发表率有显著差异，分别为47.83%（SRS）和41.53%（IMAST），p = 0.03。获提名奖的摘要发表率为63.64%（49/77），与未获提名的摘要（42.4%，290/684）有显著差异；p = 0.0004。SRS获提名奖的摘要（72.97%，27/37）和未获提名的摘要（45.25%；138/305）之间的发表率有显著差异，p = 0.0001。IMAST获提名奖的摘要（55%，21/40）和未获提名的摘要（40.1%，152/379）的发表率没有差异，p = 0.27。2010年摘要的发表率最高（45.78%），其次是2009年（43.94%），2011年最低（43.43%）。《脊柱》是这两个会议最常见的发表期刊。
在首批评估SRS和IMAST年会大会发言发表率的研究之一中，我们发现总体发表率为44.37%（SRS为47.83%，IMAST为41.53%），获提名奖论文的发表率为63.64%。
