Kirn J R, DeVoogd T J
Department of Psychology, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York 14853.
J Neurosci. 1989 Sep;9(9):3176-87. doi: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.09-09-03176.1989.
Several song-related regions in the adult zebra finch brain have substantially more neurons in males than in females. Such differences appear to arise from sex differences in circulating steroids during early posthatch life. In the present study, developmental mechanisms involved in the production of sex differences are explored by examinations of the normal time course of posthatch neurogenesis and cell death in vocal control circuits. As a first step toward determining whether rates of neuron production may be different in males and females, tritiated thymidine, a marker of cell division, was administered to zebra finches at various times during the first month after hatching. Birds were sacrificed at 60 d. The number of cells formed after hatching and present at 60 d was then evaluated in 3 vocal control regions--HVc (hyperstriatum ventralis pars caudalis) and its 2 principal targets, RA (robust nucleus of the archistriatum) and Area X. Cell death was quantified by counts of normal and pyknotic, degenerating cells made in these nuclei in additional, untreated birds of both sexes at 5 d intervals from 5 to 45 d of age. The combined results of these experiments suggest that differential cell death is a major factor in the development of sex differences in the song control system and provide the first direct evidence for sex differences in cell death in the developing telencephalon. Although developmental time tables differ among the 3 brain areas examined, at specific ages significantly higher numbers of pyknotic cells were observed in HVc, RA, and presumptive Area X in females compared to males. Peak levels of cell death in RA occur 4-6 weeks after hatching. This is about 3 weeks after the onset of sex differences in steroid levels that, in turn, lead to differential organization of song system nuclei. This pattern of results suggests that designation for death and actual cell loss are temporally dissociated in this system. Neuron proliferation for HVc and Area X, but not RA, continues throughout the first 30 d after hatching, and a significant sex difference was found in the number of cells present in HVc at 60 d that were formed after hatching. Comparisons of the timing of cell death and cell incorporation suggest that this difference may be best accounted for by differential survival of neurons formed after hatching rather than differential rates of neuron production. Neither differential neurogenesis nor differential neuron death can fully account for the apparent extreme sexual dimorphism in the number of neurons in Area X.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)
成年斑胸草雀大脑中几个与鸣叫相关的区域,雄性的神经元数量比雌性多得多。这种差异似乎源于孵化后早期循环类固醇激素的性别差异。在本研究中,通过检查孵化后神经发生和发声控制回路中细胞死亡的正常时间进程,探索了性别差异产生的发育机制。作为确定雄性和雌性神经元生成速率是否可能不同的第一步,在孵化后的第一个月内,于不同时间给斑胸草雀注射氚标记胸腺嘧啶核苷(一种细胞分裂标记物)。在60天时对鸟类实施安乐死。然后在三个发声控制区域——HVC(尾侧腹侧超纹状体)及其两个主要靶区RA(古纹状体粗核)和X区,评估孵化后形成并在60天时仍存在的细胞数量。通过对另外一些未处理的不同性别的鸟类从5日龄到45日龄每隔5天在这些核中对正常的和固缩的、正在退化的细胞进行计数,来量化细胞死亡情况。这些实验的综合结果表明,细胞死亡差异是鸣叫控制系统性别差异发育的一个主要因素,并为发育中的端脑中细胞死亡的性别差异提供了首个直接证据。尽管在所检查的三个脑区中发育时间表有所不同,但在特定年龄时,与雄性相比,在雌性的HVC、RA和推定的X区中观察到显著更多的固缩细胞。RA中细胞死亡的峰值水平出现在孵化后4 - 6周。这比类固醇水平出现性别差异开始的时间大约晚3周,而类固醇水平的性别差异又会导致鸣叫系统核团的不同组织形式。这种结果模式表明,在这个系统中,细胞注定死亡和实际细胞损失在时间上是分离的。HVC和X区的神经元增殖在孵化后的前30天内持续进行,但RA区并非如此,并且在60天时,在HVC中发现孵化后形成的细胞数量存在显著的性别差异。细胞死亡时间和细胞整合时间的比较表明,这种差异可能最好由孵化后形成的神经元的不同存活率来解释,而不是神经元生成速率的差异。无论是神经发生差异还是神经元死亡差异,都不能完全解释X区神经元数量明显的极端两性异形现象。(摘要截选至400字)