Ju Y, Liu A L, Wang H Q, Liu Y J, Liu J H, Chen A L, Chen L H, Li Y, Han Z
Department of Radiology, The First Affiliated Hospital of Dalian Medical University, Dalian 116011, China.
Zhonghua Zhong Liu Za Zhi. 2016 Nov 23;38(11):826-832. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.issn.0253-3766.2016.11.005.
To evaluate the value of single-source dual-energy CT (ssDECT) in differentiating lipid-poor adenomas from metastases in adrenal glands. From August 2011 to Oct 2014, 63 patients with 73 adrenal nodules (53 metastases proven by 5-6 months follow-up, and 20 histopathologically proven adenomas, CT value > 10 HU) underwent ssDECT scanning. The CT values of conventional polychromatic CT and virtual monochromatic images (40-140 keV) , fat-water density images and effective atomic number (eff-Z) were reconstructed on an ADW4.5 workstation and ROC curves were then constructed to evaluate the effectiveness of each parameter. The slope of spectral curve was measured and divided into 3 types: increment curve (K>0.1), straight curve (-0.1≤K≤0.1) and decrement curve (K< -0.1) according to the slope (the value of K) of spectral curve, and the curve patterns in the two groups were compared statistically. There was no statistical difference between the mean CT values of metastases (35.12±5.29)HU and lipid-poor adenomas (32.48±6.94)HU by conventional polychromatic CT (>0.05). The range of single-energy CT values of metastases [from (53.00±15.12) HU to (33.38±5.67) HU] was significantly higher than that of lipid-poor adenomas [from (26.90±26.94) HU to (28.77±10.66) HU] at energy levels ranging from 40 to 80 keV (<0.05). There was no significant difference between the single-energy CT value of metastases and lipid-poor adenomas at energy levels ranging from 90 to 140 keV (>0.05). The median fat-water concentration of metastases was -164.61 μg/cm significantly lower than that of lipid-poor adenomas (114.32 μg/cm<0.05). The eff-Z of metastases (7.76±0.15) was also significantly higher than that of lipid-poor adenomas (7.50±0.25, <0.05). When the threshold of fat-water concentration was -143.89 μg/cm the sensitivity, specificity and accuracy rate of metastasis diagnosis was 70.0%, 66.0%, and 76.7%, respectively. When the threshold of eff-Z was 7.63, the sensitivity, specificity and accuracy rate of metastasis diagnosis was 83.0%, 65.0%, and 80.4%, respectively. The lower the energy, the higher the diagnostic accuracy at energy levels ranging from 40 to 80 keV, and that of 40 keV was the highest. The spectral curves of metastases included 2 (3.8%) ascending curves, 9 (17.0%) straight curves and 42 (79.2%) descending curves, while in the 20 lipid-poor adenomas, there were 9 (45.0%) ascending curves, 4 (20.0%) straight curves and 7 (35.0%) descending curves, showing significant differences between the two groups (<0.05). Single-source dual-energy CT provides an effective multi-parameter approach for differentiating lipid-poor adrenal adenomas from metastases.
评估单源双能量CT(ssDECT)在鉴别肾上腺乏脂性腺瘤与转移瘤中的价值。2011年8月至2014年10月,63例患者共73个肾上腺结节(53个经5 - 6个月随访证实为转移瘤,20个经组织病理学证实为腺瘤,CT值>10 HU)接受了ssDECT扫描。在ADW4.5工作站上重建常规多色CT及虚拟单色图像(40 - 140 keV)的CT值、脂肪 - 水密度图像及有效原子序数(eff-Z),然后构建ROC曲线以评估各参数的有效性。测量光谱曲线的斜率并根据光谱曲线斜率(K值)分为3种类型:上升曲线(K>0.1)、直线曲线(-0.1≤K≤0.1)和下降曲线(K<-0.1),并对两组曲线类型进行统计学比较。常规多色CT显示转移瘤(35.12±5.29)HU与乏脂性腺瘤(32.48±6.94)HU的平均CT值之间无统计学差异(>0.05)。在40至80 keV能量水平下,转移瘤的单能量CT值范围[从(53.00±15.12)HU到(33.38±5.67)HU]显著高于乏脂性腺瘤[从(26.90±26.94)HU到(28.77±10.66)HU](<0.05)。在90至140 keV能量水平下,转移瘤与乏脂性腺瘤的单能量CT值无显著差异(>0.05)。转移瘤的中位脂肪 - 水浓度为-164.61μg/cm,显著低于乏脂性腺瘤(114.32μg/cm,<0.05)。转移瘤的eff-Z(7.76±0.15)也显著高于乏脂性腺瘤(7.50±0.25,<0.05)。当脂肪 - 水浓度阈值为-143.89μg/cm时,转移瘤诊断的灵敏度、特异度和准确率分别为70.0%、66.0%和76.7%。当eff-Z阈值为7.63时,转移瘤诊断的灵敏度、特异度和准确率分别为83.0%、65.0%和80.4%。在40至80 keV能量水平下,能量越低诊断准确性越高,40 keV时最高。转移瘤的光谱曲线包括2条(3.8%)上升曲线、9条(17.0%)直线曲线和42条(79.2%)下降曲线,而在20个乏脂性腺瘤中,有9条(45.0%)上升曲线、4条(20.0%)直线曲线和7条(35.0%)下降曲线,两组间差异有统计学意义(<0.05)。单源双能量CT为鉴别肾上腺乏脂性腺瘤与转移瘤提供了一种有效的多参数方法。