Sklar G S, Sonn D D, Watson W A
Department of Anesthesiology, Bronx Lebanon Hospital Center, NY.
DICP. 1989 Sep;23(9):659-62. doi: 10.1177/106002808902300905.
Butorphanol/diazepam was compared with thiopental for induction of anesthesia, and the thiopental-sparing effects of butorphanol/diazepam determined. One hundred women, American Society of Anesthesiology physical status class I, undergoing ambulatory, elective termination of pregnancy were randomized to receive either butorphanol 2 mg plus diazepam 10 mg, or thiopental, until loss of the lid reflex occurred. The butorphanol/diazepam group received supplemental thiopental as necessary to attain adequate induction of anesthesia. The combination of butorphanol and diazepam significantly reduced the thiopental dose required to produce loss of the lid reflex, from 4.2 +/- 0.8 to 0.8 +/- 0.6 mg/kg (p less than 0.005), with 22 percent of the patients not requiring supplemental thiopental. The intraoperative course and anesthetic requirements were similar between the two groups. Lower recovery room rating scale values upon arrival at the recovery room were attributed to significantly higher weight-normalized doses of butorphanol (p = 0.004) and diazepam (p = 0.005). The duration of the recovery room stay was 68.8 +/- 24.9 min for the control group, and 80.8 +/- 29.0 min for the butorphanol/diazepam-treated patients (p = 0.026). There were no clinically significant differences in anesthesia or postanesthesia recovery. The combination of butorphanol and diazepam has a significant thiopental-sparing effect, and is a useful induction technique for short, ambulatory surgical procedures.
将布托啡诺/地西泮与硫喷妥钠用于诱导麻醉进行比较,并确定布托啡诺/地西泮对硫喷妥钠的节约效应。100名美国麻醉医师协会身体状况分级为I级、接受门诊择期终止妊娠手术的女性被随机分为两组,分别接受2mg布托啡诺加10mg地西泮或硫喷妥钠,直至睑反射消失。布托啡诺/地西泮组根据需要补充硫喷妥钠以达到充分的麻醉诱导。布托啡诺与地西泮联合使用显著降低了产生睑反射消失所需的硫喷妥钠剂量,从4.2±0.8mg/kg降至0.8±0.6mg/kg(p<0.005),22%的患者不需要补充硫喷妥钠。两组的术中过程和麻醉需求相似。到达恢复室时较低的恢复室评分量表值归因于布托啡诺(p=0.004)和地西泮(p=0.005)的体重标准化剂量显著更高。对照组在恢复室的停留时间为68.8±24.9分钟,布托啡诺/地西泮治疗组患者为80.8±29.0分钟(p=0.026)。麻醉或麻醉后恢复方面无临床显著差异。布托啡诺与地西泮联合使用具有显著的硫喷妥钠节约效应,是一种适用于短时间门诊手术的有用诱导技术。