Harrison Kathryn D, McCrory Jean L
J Am Podiatr Med Assoc. 2016 Nov;106(6):406-410. doi: 10.7547/14-077.
Foot anthropometry may be altered during pregnancy. Pregnant women often report lower-extremity pain that may be related to these alterations. The Arch Height Index Measurement System is a common method of foot arch assessment; however, the required calipers are costly and are not widely available. Thus, we compared the reliability of a digital photogrammetry method of arch height index (AHI) assessment with that of the Arch Height Index Measurement System.
Ten pregnant women (mean ± SD: age, 29 ± 4 years; height, 166.9 ± 6.8 cm; weight, 63.3 ± 8.8 kg) in their second trimester were recruited to participate, along with a control group of 10 nulliparous weight-matched women (mean ± SD: age, 22 ± 2 years; height, 164.6 ± 4.8 cm; weight, 61.5 ± 8.1 kg). During the second and third trimesters, and once postpartum, AHI was assessed using calipers and using digital photogrammetry. Mixed model absolute agreement type intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was used to determine correlation between the two methods for sitting and standing AHI.
The ICC results for sitting AHI only (0.819-0.968) were reasonable for clinical measures; ICC values for standing AHI (0.674-0.789) did not reach values deemed reasonable for clinical use.
Caliper and digital photogrammetry methods of AHI assessment are correlated in pregnant women; however, for standing AHI, the correlation is not sufficient for clinical use. Photogrammetry may still be appropriate for clinical use, as long as values from this method are not substituted directly for results obtained from calipers.
孕期足部人体测量学特征可能会发生改变。孕妇常诉说下肢疼痛,这可能与这些改变有关。足弓高度指数测量系统是一种常用的足弓评估方法;然而,所需的卡尺价格昂贵且不易广泛获取。因此,我们比较了足弓高度指数(AHI)评估的数字摄影测量法与足弓高度指数测量系统的可靠性。
招募了10名孕中期孕妇(平均±标准差:年龄29±4岁;身高166.9±6.8厘米;体重63.3±8.8千克),以及10名体重匹配的未孕女性作为对照组(平均±标准差:年龄22±2岁;身高164.6±4.8厘米;体重61.5±8.1千克)。在孕中期和孕晚期以及产后一次,使用卡尺和数字摄影测量法评估AHI。采用混合模型绝对一致性类型组内相关系数(ICC)来确定两种方法在坐位和立位AHI之间的相关性。
仅坐位AHI的ICC结果(0.819 - 0.968)对于临床测量来说是合理的;立位AHI的ICC值(0.674 - 0.789)未达到临床使用认为合理的值。
在孕妇中,卡尺法和数字摄影测量法评估AHI具有相关性;然而,对于立位AHI,这种相关性不足以用于临床。只要不直接用这种方法得到的值替代卡尺测量结果,摄影测量法仍可能适用于临床。