Walling Anne, Istas Kathryn, Bonaminio Giulia A, Paolo Anthony M, Fontes Joseph D, Davis Nancy, Berardo Benito A
a Office of Faculty Affairs and Professional Development, University of Kansas School of Medicine , Wichita , Kansas.
b Office of Medical Education, University of Kansas School of Medicine , Kansas City , Kansas.
Teach Learn Med. 2017 Apr-Jun;29(2):173-180. doi: 10.1080/10401334.2016.1247708. Epub 2016 Dec 29.
Phenomenon: Medical student perspectives were sought about active learning, including concerns, challenges, perceived advantages and disadvantages, and appropriate role in the educational process.
Focus groups were conducted with students from all years and campuses of a large U.S. state medical school.
Students had considerable experience with active learning prior to medical school and conveyed accurate understanding of the concept and its major strategies. They appreciated the potential of active learning to deepen and broaden learning and its value for long-term professional development but had significant concerns about the efficiency of the process, the clarity of expectations provided, and the importance of receiving preparatory materials. Most significantly, active learning experiences were perceived as disconnected from grading and even as impeding preparation for school and national examinations. Insights: Medical students understand the concepts of active learning and have considerable experience in several formats prior to medical school. They are generally supportive of active learning concepts but frustrated by perceived inefficiencies and lack of contribution to the urgencies of achieving optimal grades and passing United States Medical Licensing Examinations, especially Step 1.
现象:征求了医学生对主动学习的看法,包括担忧、挑战、感知到的优点和缺点,以及在教育过程中的适当作用。
对一所大型美国州立医学院各年级和各校区的学生进行了焦点小组访谈。
学生在进入医学院之前就有丰富的主动学习经验,并且对这一概念及其主要策略有准确的理解。他们认识到主动学习在深化和拓展学习方面的潜力及其对长期职业发展的价值,但对学习过程的效率、所提供期望的清晰度以及获取预习材料的重要性深感担忧。最重要的是,主动学习经历被认为与评分无关,甚至被认为会妨碍备考学校考试和国家考试。见解:医学生理解主动学习的概念,并且在进入医学院之前就有多种形式的丰富经验。他们总体上支持主动学习的概念,但因感知到的效率低下以及对取得优异成绩和通过美国医师执照考试(尤其是第一步考试)的紧迫性缺乏帮助而感到沮丧。