Cho Jae-Woo, Kent William T, Yoon Yong-Cheol, Kim Youngwoo, Kim Hyungon, Jha Ashutosh, Durai Senthil Kumar, Oh Jong-Keon
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Guro Hospital, Korea University Medical Center, 148 Gurodong-ro, Guro-gu, Seoul, 08308, Republic of Korea.
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, UC Davis Medical Center, Sacramento, CA, USA.
Injury. 2017 Feb;48(2):277-284. doi: 10.1016/j.injury.2016.12.015. Epub 2016 Dec 23.
This study was designed to assess the incidence and morphology of coronal plane fragments in AO/OTA 31-A trochanteric fractures.
156 cases of AO/OTA 31-A trochanteric fractures were retrospectively evaluated. Lateral radiographs were analyzed for the presence of coronal plane fragments followed by analysis of 3D CT reconstructions in these fractures. The incidence of coronal fragments identified on the lateral radiograph and 3D CT reconstructions were both calculated. Coronal fragment morphology was described based upon the origin and exit points of fracture lines and the number of fragments.
On plain radiographs, a coronal plane fracture was identified in 59 cases, an incidence of 37.8% (59/156). In comparison, 3D CT reconstructions identified coronal plane fractures in 138 cases for an incidence of 88.4% (138/156). 3D CT reconstructions identified coronal fracture fragments in 81.9% (50/61) of AO/OTA 31-A1 cases, 94.5% (69/73) of 31-A2 cases, and 86.3% (19/22) of 31-A3 cases. Incidence of coronal fractures identified on plain radiographs of 3 AO/OTA 31-A1,A2,A3 groups was lower when compared to the incidence of coronal fractures identified on 3D CT. Of the 138 cases that had coronal plane fracture, 82 cases (59.4%) had a single coronal fragment (GT fragment 35 cases, GLT fragment 19 cases, GLPC fragment 28 cases). The remaining 56 cases (40.5%) had two coronal fragments. There is a high incidence of coronal fragments in intertrochanteric femur fractures when analyzed with 3D CT reconstructions. Our study suggests that these coronal fragments are difficult to identify on plain radiographs. Knowledge of the incidence and morphology of coronal fragments helps to avoid potential intraoperative pitfalls.
本研究旨在评估AO/OTA 31 - A型转子间骨折中冠状面骨折块的发生率及形态。
对156例AO/OTA 31 - A型转子间骨折进行回顾性评估。分析骨盆正位X线片以确定冠状面骨折块的存在情况,随后对这些骨折进行三维CT重建分析。计算在骨盆正位X线片和三维CT重建上识别出的冠状面骨折块的发生率。根据骨折线的起点和终点以及骨折块数量描述冠状面骨折块的形态。
在骨盆正位X线片上,59例发现冠状面骨折,发生率为37.8%(59/156)。相比之下,三维CT重建发现138例冠状面骨折,发生率为88.4%(138/156)。三维CT重建在81.9%(50/61)的AO/OTA 31 - A1型骨折、94.5%(69/73)的31 - A2型骨折和86.3%(19/22)的31 - A3型骨折中发现冠状面骨折块。与三维CT相比,AO/OTA 31 - A1、A2、A3三组骨盆正位X线片上识别出的冠状面骨折发生率较低。在138例冠状面骨折病例中,82例(59.4%)有单个冠状面骨折块(大转子骨折块35例,小转子-大转子骨折块19例,小转子-梨状肌嵴骨折块28例)。其余56例(40.5%)有两个冠状面骨折块。使用三维CT重建分析时,股骨转子间骨折中冠状面骨折块的发生率较高。我们的研究表明,这些冠状面骨折块在骨盆正位X线片上难以识别。了解冠状面骨折块的发生率和形态有助于避免潜在的术中陷阱。