Palocaren Jeeji, Pillai Lekha S, Celine T M
Department of Biochemistry, Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church Medical College, Kolenchery 682311, Kerala, India.
Department of Community Medicine, Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church Medical College, Kolenchery 682311, Kerala, India.
Natl Med J India. 2016 Jul-Aug;29(4):222-224.
The Medical Council of India (MCI) recommendations on medical education suggest a shift from didactic lectures to more interactive lectures. This study assessed the effectiveness of different pedagogical methods in biochemistry and the perceptions of students and teachers about the shift from didactic to interactive lectures.
An interventional crossover study was done with the topic divided into three biochemical modules and one clinical module. The students were divided into two batches, one of which was given didactic and the other, interactive lectures. They were assessed immediately after the lecture and four months later. Anonymous feedback was obtained to gauge the students' perceptions regarding the mode of teaching. The teachers' feedback on the use of both pedagogical styles was also obtained.
There was no significant difference between the performance of the two groups in either examination in three of the modules. However, there was a statistically significant difference between the two groups' performance in the module that had clinical applications, with students from the interactive lecture group performing better. All students preferred interactive classes, irrespective of the topic taught. The teachers indicated that, although at the outset the interactive lectures were difficult to manage, both in terms of content and time, these drawbacks could be overcome with time and practice.
Interactive lectures are an effective teaching method in biochemistry, especially in topics involving clinical application.
印度医学委员会(MCI)关于医学教育的建议提出从讲授式讲座转向更具互动性的讲座。本研究评估了生物化学中不同教学方法的有效性以及学生和教师对从讲授式讲座转向互动式讲座的看法。
进行了一项干预性交叉研究,主题分为三个生物化学模块和一个临床模块。学生被分为两批,一批接受讲授式讲座,另一批接受互动式讲座。讲座结束后立即对他们进行评估,并在四个月后再次评估。通过匿名反馈来了解学生对教学模式的看法。同时也获取了教师对两种教学方式使用情况的反馈。
在三个模块的两次考试中,两组学生的成绩均无显著差异。然而,在有临床应用的模块中,两组学生的成绩存在统计学上的显著差异,互动式讲座组的学生表现更好。所有学生都更喜欢互动式课程,无论所教授的主题是什么。教师表示,虽然一开始互动式讲座在内容和时间方面都难以管理,但随着时间的推移和实践,这些缺点是可以克服的。
互动式讲座是生物化学中一种有效的教学方法,尤其是在涉及临床应用的主题中。