Nganvongpanit Korakot, Buddhachat Kittisak, Piboon Promporn, Euppayo Thippaporn, Mahakkanukrauh Pasuk
Animal Bone and Joint Research Laboratory, Department of Veterinary Biosciences and Public Health, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Chiang Mai University, Chiang Mai 50100, Thailand.
Animal Bone and Joint Research Laboratory, Department of Veterinary Biosciences and Public Health, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Chiang Mai University, Chiang Mai 50100, Thailand; Department of Biology, Faculty of Science, Naresuan University, Phitsanulok 65000, Thailand.
Forensic Sci Int. 2017 Feb;271:33-42. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2016.12.017. Epub 2016 Dec 21.
Identifying human remains is a primary task in forensic science. In this study, we propose a possible new technique, handheld X-ray fluorescence (HHXRF), for determining whether a suspected tooth is an authentic human tooth. A total of 444 teeth obtained from 111 human skulls (male=62, female=49) aged between 30-67 years (51.81±8.37 years) were used as subjects. The teeth were scanned by HHXRF to acquire their elemental profile. Differences in elemental composition were analyzed for different tooth positions (numbers 1-32), between crown and root, and between sexes (male and female); also, the proportion of elements in relation to different human ages was examined. Teeth from 20 different animal species, serving as non-human teeth samples, were used to distinguish between human and non-human teeth through a stepwise discriminant analysis. Our results revealed that different tooth positions, different regions (crown and root) of a tooth, and different sexes demonstrated disparities in the proportion of several elements. The accuracy rate of predicting sex based on the elemental profile of human teeth was 65.5%. Likewise, a dissimilar distribution of elements between human and non-human teeth was observed, leading to a high degree of correctness of 83.2% for distinguishing them. In conclusion, elemental analysis by HHXRF could serve as a promising candidate tool for identifying human teeth in forensic science, but is ineffective for sex determination.
识别遗体身份是法医学的一项主要任务。在本研究中,我们提出了一种可能的新技术——手持式X射线荧光光谱法(HHXRF),用于确定一颗疑似人类牙齿是否为真牙。我们使用了从111具年龄在30至67岁(平均年龄51.81±8.37岁)的人类头骨(男性62具,女性49具)上获取的444颗牙齿作为研究对象。用HHXRF对这些牙齿进行扫描以获取其元素谱。分析了不同牙齿位置(1至32号)、牙冠与牙根以及不同性别(男性和女性)之间的元素组成差异;此外,还研究了元素比例与不同人类年龄的关系。选取了20种不同动物的牙齿作为非人类牙齿样本,通过逐步判别分析来区分人类牙齿和非人类牙齿。我们的研究结果显示,不同的牙齿位置、牙齿的不同区域(牙冠和牙根)以及不同性别在几种元素的比例上存在差异。基于人类牙齿元素谱预测性别的准确率为65.5%。同样,观察到人类牙齿和非人类牙齿之间元素分布不同,区分两者的正确率高达83.2%。总之,HHXRF元素分析可作为法医学中识别人类牙齿的一种有前景的候选工具,但对性别判定无效。