Taing Kim Det, O'Brien Terence J, Williams David A, French Chris R
Department of Medicine (Royal Melbourne Hospital), The University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
PLoS One. 2017 Jan 11;12(1):e0169974. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0169974. eCollection 2017.
In this study, we investigated the relative efficacy of different classes of commonly used anti-epileptic drugs (AEDs) with different mechanisms of action, individually and in combination, to suppress epileptiform discharges in an in vitro model. Extracellular field potential were recorded in 450 μm thick transverse hippocampal slices prepared from juvenile Wistar rats, in which "epileptiform discharges" (ED's) were produced with a high-K+ (8.5 mM) bicarbonate-buffered saline solution. Single and dual recordings in stratum pyramidale of CA1 and CA3 regions were performed with 3-5 MΩ glass microelectrodes. All drugs-lamotrigine (LTG), phenytoin (PHT) and valproate (VPA)-were applied to the slice by superfusion at a rate of 2 ml/min at 32°C. Effects upon frequency of ED's were assessed for LTG, PHT and VPA applied at different concentrations, in isolation and in combination. We demonstrated that high-K+ induced ED frequency was reversibly reduced by LTG, PHT and VPA, at concentrations corresponding to human therapeutic blood plasma concentrations. With a protocol using several applications of drugs to the same slice, PHT and VPA in combination displayed additivity of effect with 50μM PHT and 350μM VPA reducing SLD frequency by 44% and 24% individually (n = 19), and together reducing SLD frequency by 66% (n = 19). 20μM LTG reduced SLD frequency by 32% and 350μM VPA by 16% (n = 18). However, in combination there was a supra-linear suppression of ED's of 64% (n = 18). In another independent set of experiments, similar results of drug combination responses were also found. In conclusion, a combination of conventional AEDs with different mechanisms of action, PHT and VPA, displayed linear additivity of effect on epileptiform activity. More intriguingly, a combination of LTG and VPA considered particularly efficacious clinically showed a supra-additive suppression of ED's. This approach may be useful as an in vitro platform for assessing drug combination efficacy.
在本研究中,我们调查了不同作用机制的常用抗癫痫药物(AEDs)单独及联合使用时,在体外模型中抑制癫痫样放电的相对疗效。在从幼年Wistar大鼠制备的450μm厚的海马横切片中记录细胞外场电位,其中用高钾(8.5 mM)碳酸氢盐缓冲盐溶液诱导产生“癫痫样放电”(EDs)。使用3 - 5 MΩ的玻璃微电极在CA1和CA3区的锥体层进行单通道和双通道记录。所有药物——拉莫三嗪(LTG)、苯妥英(PHT)和丙戊酸盐(VPA)——在32℃下以2 ml/min的速率通过灌流施加到切片上。评估了不同浓度的LTG、PHT和VPA单独及联合使用时对EDs频率的影响。我们证明,在相当于人类治疗血浆浓度的浓度下,LTG、PHT和VPA可使高钾诱导的ED频率可逆性降低。采用向同一切片多次施加药物的方案,PHT和VPA联合使用显示出效果的相加性,50μM PHT和350μM VPA分别使癫痫样放电(SLD)频率降低44%和24%(n = 19),两者联合使SLD频率降低66%(n = 19)。20μM LTG使SLD频率降低32%,350μM VPA使SLD频率降低16%(n = 18)。然而,联合使用时对EDs有超线性抑制作用,抑制率为64%(n = 18)。在另一组独立实验中,也发现了药物联合反应的类似结果。总之,具有不同作用机制的传统AEDs,PHT和VPA联合使用时,对癫痫样活动显示出线性相加作用。更有趣的是,临床上认为特别有效的LTG和VPA联合使用对EDs有超相加抑制作用。这种方法可作为评估药物联合疗效的体外平台。