Harahsheh Ashraf S, O'Byrne Michael L, Pastor Bill, Graham Dionne A, Fulton David R
1 Children's National Health System, Washington, DC, USA.
2 George Washington University, Washington, DC, USA.
Clin Pediatr (Phila). 2017 Nov;56(13):1201-1208. doi: 10.1177/0009922816684605. Epub 2017 Jan 12.
We conducted a study to assess test characteristics of red-flag criteria for identifying cardiac disease causing chest pain and technical charges of low-probability referrals. Accuracy of red-flag criteria was ascertained through study of chest pain Standardized Clinical Assessment and Management Plans (SCAMPs®) data. Patients were divided into 2 groups: Group1 (concerning clinical elements) and Group2 (without). We compared incidence of cardiac disease causing chest pain between these 2 groups. Technical charges of Group 2 were analyzed using the Pediatric Health Information System database. Potential savings for the US population was estimated using National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey data. Fifty-two percent of subjects formed Group 1. Cardiac disease causing chest pain was identified in 8/1656 (0.48%). No heart disease was identified in patients in Group 2 ( P = .03). Applying red-flags in determining need for referral identified patients with cardiac disease causing chest pain with 100% sensitivity. Median technical charges for Group 2, over a 4-year period, were US2014$775 559. Eliminating cardiac testing of low-probability referrals would save US2014$3 775 182 in technical charges annually. Red-flag criteria were an effective screen for children with chest pain. Eliminating cardiac testing in children without red-flags for referral has significant technical charge savings.
我们开展了一项研究,以评估用于识别引起胸痛的心脏病的警示标准的检测特征以及低概率转诊的技术费用。通过对胸痛标准化临床评估与管理计划(SCAMPs®)数据的研究来确定警示标准的准确性。患者被分为两组:第1组(涉及临床因素)和第2组(不涉及)。我们比较了这两组中由胸痛引起的心脏病的发病率。使用儿科健康信息系统数据库分析了第2组的技术费用。利用国家门诊医疗调查数据估算了美国人群的潜在节省费用。52%的受试者构成第1组。在1656名受试者中有8名(0.48%)被诊断为由胸痛引起的心脏病。第2组患者未发现心脏病(P = 0.03)。在确定转诊需求时应用警示标准,对由胸痛引起的心脏病患者的识别敏感性为100%。第2组在4年期间的技术费用中位数为2014年美元775,559。取消低概率转诊的心脏检查每年可节省2014年美元3,775,182的技术费用。警示标准是对胸痛儿童的一种有效筛查方法。取消对无转诊警示标志儿童的心脏检查可显著节省技术费用。