Thomas Sanjeev V, Jose Manna, Divakaran Srividya, Sankara Sarma Prabhakaran
Kerala Registry of Epilepsy and Pregnancy Study Group, Department of Neurology, Sree Chitra Tirunal Institute for Medical Sciences and Technology, Trivandrum, Kerala, India.
Epilepsia. 2017 Feb;58(2):274-281. doi: 10.1111/epi.13632. Epub 2017 Jan 13.
Kerala Registry of Epilepsy and Pregnancy had been prospectively evaluating the reproductive issues of women with epilepsy since April 1998. This analysis aimed to estimate the relative risk of major congenital malformations (MCM) to the registrants.
All pregnancies with known outcome in this register until December 2013 were included. Malformation status was evaluated by antenatal ultrasonography, physical examination at birth, echocardiography, and abdomen ultrasonography at 3 months of age and a final review at 1 year of age.
There were 1,688 fetuses (singlets 1,643, twins 21, and triplet 1) resulting in 1,622 live births. All were born to women of Asian origin living in South India. The MCM rate for all live births was 6.84% (95% confidence interval [CI] 5.71-8.18) and for all pregnancy outcomes including fetal loss was 7.11% (95% CI 5.98-8.44). The MCM rates (mean with 95% CI) for exposed group were 6.4% (5.03-8.03) for monotherapy and 9.9% (7.37-13.13) for polytherapy; internal control group (women with epilepsy [WWE] not on antiepileptic drugs [AEDs] in first trimester) 5.6% (3.34-9.11), external control group (women without epilepsy or AED exposure in first trimester) 3.45% (1.94-6.07). Valproate monotherapy group had a dose-dependent relative risk for MCM of 2.6 (95% CI 1.30-5.20) compared to the external control group. The preliminary data on MCM rate for the nine total clobazam monotherapy (22.2%; 95% CI 6.2-54.7) signals increased risk that needs further validation on larger sample size. There was no association between MCM rate and maternal socioeconomic status, epilepsy syndrome, or use of folic acid in first trimester.
This dataset from South India confirms the increased risk of MCM with exposure to AEDs, particularly polytherapy. A dose-dependent increased risk was observed with valproate. The increased risk associated with clobazam monotherapy is an important signal that needs to be confirmed in a larger sample.
喀拉拉邦癫痫与妊娠登记处自1998年4月起对癫痫女性的生殖问题进行前瞻性评估。本分析旨在估计登记者发生重大先天性畸形(MCM)的相对风险。
纳入该登记处截至2013年12月所有已知结局的妊娠病例。通过产前超声、出生时体格检查、超声心动图、3月龄腹部超声以及1岁时的最终复查来评估畸形状况。
共有1688例胎儿(单胎1643例、双胎21例、三胎1例),共娩出1622例活产儿。所有产妇均为居住在印度南部的亚洲裔女性。所有活产儿的MCM发生率为6.84%(95%置信区间[CI]5.71 - 8.18),包括胎儿丢失在内的所有妊娠结局的MCM发生率为7.11%(95%CI 5.98 - 8.44)。暴露组单药治疗的MCM发生率(均值及95%CI)为6.4%(5.03 - 8.03),联合治疗为9.9%(7.37 - 13.13);内部对照组(孕早期未服用抗癫痫药物[AEDs]的癫痫女性[WWE])为5.6%(3.34 - 9.11),外部对照组(孕早期无癫痫或未接触AEDs的女性)为3.45%(1.94 - 6.07)。与外部对照组相比,丙戊酸单药治疗组MCM的剂量依赖性相对风险为2.6(95%CI 1.30 - 5.20)。九例氯巴占单药治疗的MCM发生率的初步数据(22.2%;95%CI 6.2 - 54.7)表明风险增加,需要在更大样本量上进一步验证。MCM发生率与产妇社会经济状况、癫痫综合征或孕早期叶酸使用之间无关联。
来自印度南部的该数据集证实了暴露于AEDs尤其是联合治疗会增加MCM风险。观察到丙戊酸存在剂量依赖性风险增加。氯巴占单药治疗相关的风险增加是一个重要信号,需要在更大样本中得到证实。