Lee Cheuk Yan, Furnham Adrian, Merritt Christopher
a Research Department of Clinical, Educational and Health Psychology, University College London , London , UK.
b Norwegian Business School (BI) , Nydalveien , Olso , Norway and.
J Ment Health. 2017 Jun;26(3):257-263. doi: 10.1080/09638237.2016.1276531. Epub 2017 Jan 13.
Research has demonstrated that Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) is one of the most widely recognized mental disorders, but recognition is affected by trauma type.
The current study investigated the effect of direct versus indirect exposure to traumatic event and trauma types on Mental Health Literacy (MHL) of PTSD.
Two hundred and thirty-three participants were asked to identify the mental health problem after presentation of an unlabeled vignette describing a character experiencing PTSD symptoms. The six vignettes described the same symptoms but differed in directness (direct/indirect exposure) and trauma type (rape, military combat or man-made disaster). It was hypothesized that (1) recognition rate would be higher in direct than indirect conditions, and (2) higher in military combat, followed by man-made disaster, and lowest in rape condition.
Overall, correct recognition of PTSD was 42.5%. Recognition in direct exposure vignettes was significantly higher than indirect, supporting the first hypothesis. The second hypothesis was only partly supported. While PTSD recognition in rape vignettes was significantly lower than the other two scenarios, no difference was found between combat and man-made disaster trauma types.
Our findings implied under-recognition of PTSD, with lack of awareness of different causes of PTSD and of PTSD from indirect trauma exposure. The latter finding is important in the light of DSM-V revisions to diagnostic criteria for PTSD.
研究表明,创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)是最广为人知的精神障碍之一,但认知情况受创伤类型影响。
本研究调查了直接暴露与间接暴露于创伤事件以及创伤类型对PTSD心理健康素养(MHL)的影响。
向233名参与者展示一个未标明的小插曲,描述一个出现PTSD症状的人物,要求他们识别心理健康问题。六个小插曲描述了相同的症状,但在直接性(直接/间接暴露)和创伤类型(强奸、军事战斗或人为灾难)方面有所不同。研究假设为:(1)直接暴露条件下的识别率高于间接暴露条件;(2)军事战斗场景下的识别率最高,其次是人为灾难场景,强奸场景下的识别率最低。
总体而言,PTSD的正确识别率为42.5%。直接暴露小插曲中的识别率显著高于间接暴露小插曲,支持了第一个假设。第二个假设仅得到部分支持。虽然强奸小插曲中PTSD的识别率显著低于其他两种场景,但军事战斗和人为灾难创伤类型之间未发现差异。
我们的研究结果表明对PTSD认识不足,对PTSD的不同病因以及间接创伤暴露导致的PTSD缺乏认识。鉴于《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第五版(DSM-V)对PTSD诊断标准的修订,后一个发现很重要。