Few Julius, Gold Michael, Sadick Neil
J Drugs Dermatol. 2016 Nov 1;15(11):1354-1358.
Increasing demand for non-invasive skin tightening and body contouring procedures has led to several technological in- novations in energy-based devices such as ultrasound, radiofrequency and cryolipolysis. An emerging trend in the eld is to evaluate whether combination therapies for skin laxity/body contouring using energy-based devices can deliver superior clinical results and patient satisfaction. As such, the objective of this prospective, internal-controlled, blind clinical study was to assess the safety and efficacy of cryolipolysis followed by multipolar radiofrequency with pulsed electromagnetic elds (PEMF) and adjustable pulsed suction for the treatment of skin laxity in the flanks.
Ten subjects with focal adiposities in the anks were enrolled in the study. All subjects received one session of cryolipolysis treatment and after randomization received two sessions of radiofrequency with PEMF (spaced two weeks apart), followed by another two sessions of radiofrequency with PEMF and adjustable pulsed suction (spaced two weeks apart). Clinical photography was used to monitor the subject's results at baseline, one week, three, and six months post treatment. Blinded reviewers and the treating inves- tigator assessed the clinical outcomes using the Global Aesthetic Improvement (GAI) scale. Side effects were recorded at every visit and patient satisfaction was noted at the one week, three and six-month follow-up using a 5-scale subject satisfaction assessment questionnaire.
Analysis of the blinded investigator ratings demonstrated statistical significant enhanced skin laxity mean improvement of 1 grade on the GAI scale in subject treated with the combination treatment (cryolipolysis+RF/PEMF/suction) compared with the cryolipolysis treatment alone. The unblinded investigator GAI ratings also showed enhanced (20%) mean improvement of laxity in the combination treated subjects versus those receiving cryolipolysis alone. Over half of the participants reported satisfaction with both treatment results, but there was a 10% statistically significant higher satisfaction rating of the outcomes in the flank treated with the combination treatment. Procedures were well tolerated, side effects were transient and self-resolving and no unexpected adverse effects were reported for the duration of the study.
The results of this study show that the combination of multipolar RF with PEMF/suction following cryolipolysis is a safe, effective, and painless approach to enhance skin tightening following fat reduction procedures in the flanks. J Drugs Dermatol. 2016;15(11):1354-1358..
对非侵入性皮肤紧致和身体塑形手术的需求不断增加,促使基于能量的设备出现了多项技术创新,如超声、射频和冷冻溶脂术。该领域的一个新兴趋势是评估使用基于能量的设备进行皮肤松弛/身体塑形的联合疗法是否能带来更好的临床效果和患者满意度。因此,这项前瞻性、自身对照、盲法临床研究的目的是评估冷冻溶脂术联合多极射频加脉冲电磁场(PEMF)和可调脉冲抽吸治疗侧腹皮肤松弛的安全性和有效性。
招募了10名侧腹有局部脂肪堆积的受试者。所有受试者均接受了一次冷冻溶脂治疗,随机分组后接受两次射频加PEMF治疗(间隔两周),随后再接受两次射频加PEMF和可调脉冲抽吸治疗(间隔两周)。在基线、治疗后1周、3个月和6个月时,使用临床照片监测受试者的治疗效果。盲法评估者和主刀研究者使用全球美学改善(GAI)量表评估临床结果。每次就诊时记录副作用,并在1周、3个月和6个月随访时使用5级受试者满意度评估问卷记录患者满意度。
对盲法研究者评分的分析表明,与单纯冷冻溶脂治疗相比,联合治疗(冷冻溶脂 + 射频/PEMF/抽吸)的受试者在GAI量表上皮肤松弛平均改善程度有统计学意义的增强,提高了1级。非盲法研究者的GAI评分也显示,联合治疗的受试者与单纯接受冷冻溶脂治疗的受试者相比,松弛平均改善程度增强了(20%)。超过一半的参与者对两种治疗结果均表示满意,但联合治疗侧腹的满意度评分在统计学上显著高出10%。手术耐受性良好,副作用短暂且可自行缓解,在研究期间未报告意外不良事件。
本研究结果表明,冷冻溶脂术后联合多极射频与PEMF/抽吸是一种安全、有效且无痛的方法,可在侧腹减脂术后增强皮肤紧致效果。《药物皮肤病学杂志》。2016年;15(11):1354 - 1358。