Even-Zohar Gross Noa, Geva-Eldar Talia, Pollak Yehuda, Hirsch Harry J, Gross Itai, Gross-Tsur Varda
Department of Internal Medicine, Hadassah Medical Center, Jerusalem, Israel.
Seymour Fox School of Education, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Jerusalem, Israel; Reproductive Endocrinology and Genetics Unit, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Shaare Zedek Medical Center, Jerusalem, Israel.
Eur J Med Genet. 2017 Apr;60(4):205-211. doi: 10.1016/j.ejmg.2017.01.003. Epub 2017 Jan 22.
Prenatal diagnosis (PND) raises ethical dilemmas such as the option of termination of pregnancy (TOP) in cases with severe outcome. Prader-Willi Syndrome (PWS), a complex neurogenetic syndrome with high morbidity and mortality throughout life. Recently, a unique prenatal phenotype was reported and TOP becomes a possibility.
To explore factors influencing the attitudes of parents of PWS children toward PND and TOP concerning a hypothetical pregnancy with a PWS fetus.
All 85 parents of individuals with PWS were interviewed regarding their attitudes towards PND and TOP using semi-structured questionnaire.
Fifty-seven parents were supportive of invasive PND and 28 of non-invasive tests only; none opposed PND. Thirty eight favored TOP, additional 31 supported TOP under certain conditions such as spiritual advice, 15 were categorically against TOP. Attitudes correlated with religiosity (p < 0.025), mother's education (p < 0.001), mother's work status (p < 0.001), current age of the child with PWS (p < 0.008). Couples had similar attitudes regarding PND and TOP. No correlation was found with gender, genetic subtype and parental age.
Most parents of individuals with PWS support PND, however less than half support TOP. Religiosity was the most influential factor. Familial worldview should be taken into account during prenatal counseling.
产前诊断引发了一些伦理困境,比如在出现严重后果的情况下可选择终止妊娠。普拉德-威利综合征(PWS)是一种复杂的神经遗传综合征,患者一生的发病率和死亡率都很高。最近,一种独特的产前表型被报道出来,这使得终止妊娠成为一种可能。
探讨PWS患儿父母对于假定怀有PWS胎儿的妊娠进行产前诊断及终止妊娠的态度的影响因素。
采用半结构化问卷,就85位PWS患者的父母对产前诊断及终止妊娠的态度进行了访谈。
57位家长支持侵入性产前诊断,28位仅支持非侵入性检测;无人反对产前诊断。38位家长赞成终止妊娠,另外31位在某些条件下(如接受精神方面的建议)支持终止妊娠,15位坚决反对终止妊娠。态度与宗教信仰(p < 0.025)、母亲的教育程度(p < 0.001)、母亲的工作状况(p < 0.001)、PWS患儿的当前年龄(p < 0.008)相关。夫妻双方对产前诊断及终止妊娠的态度相似。未发现与性别、基因亚型及父母年龄存在相关性。
大多数PWS患者的父母支持产前诊断,然而支持终止妊娠的不到一半。宗教信仰是最具影响力的因素。产前咨询时应考虑家庭的世界观。