Nairn Stuart, Pinnock David
School of Health Sciences, Royal Derby Hospital, University of Nottingham, Derby, UK.
Division of Nursing, Clinical leadership for Innovative Practice (CLIP) post grad certificate Department, The University of Nottingham, QMC, Nottingham, UK.
Nurs Philos. 2017 Oct;18(4). doi: 10.1111/nup.12167. Epub 2017 Jan 30.
Bourdieu is an important thinker within the sociological tradition and has a philosophically sophisticated approach to theoretical knowledge and research practice. In this paper, we examine the implication of his work for nursing and the health sciences more broadly. We argue that his work is best described as a reflexive realist who provides a space for a nonpositivist approach to knowledge that does not fall into the trap of idealism or relativism. We emphasize that Bourdieu was not an abstract theorist, but only utilized theories to understand and explain the social world in all its empirical complexity. Theory is emphasized over method without denying the importance of method. We then provide a brief overview of some of his key concepts: habitus, field and capital. His work is a scientifically astute practice that has an emancipatory purpose, with particular resonance to the problems of nursing as a social practice. Some have criticized Bourdieu for undermining agency and we briefly address this issue, but argue that his conceptual framework helps us to understand what endures in social practice and why change is often problematic. In short, this paper argues that Bourdieu's work is a fruitful resource for critiquing existing nursing approaches that are preoccupied with agency over structure.
布迪厄是社会学传统中的一位重要思想家,在理论知识和研究实践方面有着哲学上的成熟方法。在本文中,我们更广泛地考察了他的著作对护理和健康科学的影响。我们认为,他的著作最好被描述为一种反思性现实主义,为一种非实证主义的知识方法提供了空间,这种方法不会陷入唯心主义或相对主义的陷阱。我们强调,布迪厄不是一个抽象的理论家,而是仅运用理论来理解和解释具有所有经验复杂性的社会世界。在不否认方法重要性的情况下,理论比方法更受重视。然后,我们简要概述他的一些关键概念:惯习、场域和资本。他的著作是一种具有科学敏锐性且有解放目的的实践,与护理作为一种社会实践的问题特别相关。一些人批评布迪厄削弱了能动性,我们简要讨论了这个问题,但认为他的概念框架有助于我们理解社会实践中持续存在的东西以及为什么变革往往存在问题。简而言之,本文认为布迪厄的著作是批判现有过于关注能动性而非结构的护理方法的丰富资源。