Gilchrist Elizabeth Allison, Ireland Lana, Forsyth Alasdair, Godwin Jon, Laxton Tim
Institute of Health and Society, University of Worcester, Worcester, UK.
Department of Psychology, Social Work and Allied Health Sciences, Glasgow Caledonian University, Glasgow, UK.
Drug Alcohol Rev. 2017 Jan;36(1):20-23. doi: 10.1111/dar.12505.
Scotland has a particular problem with alcohol, and the links between intimate partner abuse (IPA) and alcohol appear stronger here than elsewhere across Europe. This study explored differences in alcohol use, related aggression and relationship conflict across a number of groups: men convicted for intimate partner abuse, men convicted of general offences and men recruited from community sports teams.
Participants (n = 64) completed three questionnaires exploring their experiences of alcohol use (Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test, AUDIT); alcohol and aggression (Alcohol Related Aggression Questionnaire, ARAQ-28), and relationship conflict (Revised Conflict Tactics Scale, CTS-2).
There were significant differences across the groups in terms of AUDIT and ARAQ-28 scores, IPA and general offenders scored higher than the community sample. CTS-2 scores showed significant differences: both offender groups reported more use of negotiation and psychological abuse, than the community men, and IPA offenders reported causing more physical harm than either general offenders or the community sample. ARAQ-28 scores correlated with psychological abuse for general offenders. Alcohol use was very high across all groups, but the community group did not endorse an aggression-precipitating view of alcohol and did not report high IPA.
Discussed is the need for cross-cultural research to explore putative mediators and moderators in the relationship between alcohol, aggressiveness and IPA. [Gilchrist EA, Ireland L, Forsyth A, Godwin J, Laxton T. Alcohol use, alcohol-related aggression and intimate partner abuse: A cross-sectional survey of convicted versus general population men in Scotland. Drug Alcohol Rev 2017;36:20-23].
苏格兰存在严重的酒精问题,相较于欧洲其他地区,亲密伴侣虐待(IPA)与酒精之间的联系在苏格兰似乎更为紧密。本研究探讨了多个群体在饮酒、相关攻击行为及关系冲突方面的差异:因亲密伴侣虐待被定罪的男性、因一般犯罪被定罪的男性以及从社区运动队招募的男性。
参与者(n = 64)完成了三份问卷,分别探讨他们的饮酒经历(酒精使用障碍识别测试,AUDIT)、酒精与攻击行为(酒精相关攻击问卷,ARAQ - 28)以及关系冲突(修订后的冲突策略量表,CTS - 2)。
在AUDIT和ARAQ - 28得分方面,各群体之间存在显著差异,亲密伴侣虐待者和一般犯罪者的得分高于社区样本。CTS - 2得分也显示出显著差异:两个犯罪者群体报告的谈判和心理虐待使用频率均高于社区男性,亲密伴侣虐待犯罪者报告造成的身体伤害比一般犯罪者或社区样本更多。对于一般犯罪者,ARAQ - 28得分与心理虐待相关。所有群体的饮酒量都很高,但社区群体不认同酒精会引发攻击行为的观点,也未报告高亲密伴侣虐待率。
讨论了开展跨文化研究以探索酒精、攻击性和亲密伴侣虐待之间关系中假定的中介因素和调节因素的必要性。[吉尔克里斯特EA,爱尔兰L,福赛思A,戈德温J,拉克斯顿T。饮酒、酒精相关攻击行为与亲密伴侣虐待:对苏格兰被定罪男性与普通男性的横断面调查。药物酒精评论2017;36:20 - 23]