Guichard Anne, Tardieu Émilie, Dagenais Christian, Nour Kareen, Lafontaine Ginette, Ridde Valéry
Université Laval, Québec, Canada.
Université Laval, Québec, Canada.
Eval Program Plann. 2017 Apr;61:169-177. doi: 10.1016/j.evalprogplan.2017.01.003. Epub 2017 Jan 7.
The aim of this project was to identify and prioritize a set of conditions to be considered for incorporating a health equity tool into public health practice. Concept mapping and focus groups were implemented as complementary methods to investigate the conditions of use of a health equity tool by public health organizations in Quebec. Using a hybrid integrated research design is a richer way to address the complexity of questions emerging from intervention and planning settings. This approach provides a deeper, operational, and contextualized understanding of research results involving different professional and organizational cultures, and thereby supports the decision-making process. Concept mapping served to identify and prioritize in a limited timeframe the conditions to be considered for incorporation into a health equity tool into public health practices. Focus groups then provided a more refined understanding of the barriers, issues, and facilitating factors surrounding the tools adoption, helped distinguish among participants' perspectives based on functional roles and organizational contexts, and clarified some apparently contradictory results from the concept map. The combined use of these two techniques brought the strengths of each approach to bear, thereby overcoming some of the respective limitations of concept mapping and focus groups. This design is appropriate for investigating targets with multiple levels of complexity.
本项目的目的是确定并优先考虑一系列条件,以便将健康公平工具纳入公共卫生实践。概念映射和焦点小组被用作互补方法,以调查魁北克公共卫生组织使用健康公平工具的条件。采用混合综合研究设计是应对干预和规划环境中出现的复杂问题的更丰富方式。这种方法能更深入、实际且结合背景地理解涉及不同专业和组织文化的研究结果,从而支持决策过程。概念映射有助于在有限时间内确定并优先考虑将健康公平工具纳入公共卫生实践时需考虑的条件。焦点小组随后对围绕工具采用的障碍、问题和促进因素提供了更细致的理解,有助于根据职能角色和组织背景区分参与者的观点,并澄清了概念映射中一些明显矛盾的结果。这两种技术的结合发挥了每种方法的优势,从而克服了概念映射和焦点小组各自的一些局限性。这种设计适用于调查具有多层次复杂性的目标。