Berger Anthony P, Giacalone Joseph C, Barlow Patrick, Kapadia Muneera R, Keith Jerrod N
Department of Surgery, University of Iowa Roy J. and Lucille A. Carver College of Medicine, Iowa City, IA.
Department of Surgery, University of Iowa Roy J. and Lucille A. Carver College of Medicine, Iowa City, IA.
Surgery. 2017 Jun;161(6):1683-1689. doi: 10.1016/j.surg.2016.12.016. Epub 2017 Feb 1.
Few studies have explored the factors associated with the preference of medical students to pursue a specific specialty, and even fewer have observed how these preferences and factors change over time.
A longitudinal survey of medical students was administered at the beginning of first year, second year, and clerkships from 2013-2016. Surveys included demographics and factors associated with their choice of specialty.
Response rates were 78-94%. Students with mentors and research experience in any specialty were 3.4 times (P < .001) more likely to choose surgery by their third year of medical school. Surgical research experience on the first- and second-year surveys was associated with 39 (P < .001) and 10 times (P < .001) greater odds of preferring surgical specialties on their third-year survey. Medical students who had a surgery mentor during the first and second years were associated with 4 (P = .024) and 13 times (P < .001) greater odds of preferring surgical specialties on their third-year survey.
Students who begin surgical research during their first year and develop relationships with surgeon mentors during their second year are significantly more likely to maintain an interest in surgical specialties.
很少有研究探讨与医学生选择特定专业偏好相关的因素,而且观察这些偏好和因素如何随时间变化的研究更少。
在2013年至2016年期间,于医学生第一年、第二年开始时以及实习期间进行了一项纵向调查。调查内容包括人口统计学信息以及与他们专业选择相关的因素。
回复率为78%至94%。在医学院第三年时,有导师且有任何专业研究经验的学生选择外科的可能性是其他学生的3.4倍(P <.001)。在第一年和第二年调查中有外科研究经验的学生,在第三年调查中选择外科专业的几率分别高出39倍(P <.001)和10倍(P <.001)。在第一年和第二年有外科导师的医学生,在第三年调查中选择外科专业的几率分别高出4倍(P =.024)和13倍(P <.001)。
在第一年开始进行外科研究并在第二年与外科导师建立关系的学生,更有可能持续对外科专业保持兴趣。