Singh Dhananjay, Awasthi Bhanu, Padha Vikas, Thakur Sanjay
Department of Orthopaedics, Dr. Rajendra Prasad Government Medical College, Kangra, Himachal Pradesh, India.
J Orthop Case Rep. 2016 Sep-Oct;6(4):57-61. doi: 10.13107/jocr.2250-0685.570.
We report a case of Type 1 Monteggia equivalent injury with intact radio-capitellar congruity, associated with epiphyseal fracture of distal radius and distal ulna shaft in an 11-year-old boy. There are only a few cases of Monteggia or Monteggia equivalent injury with ipsilateral forearm fractures in children, and injury pattern being reported by us is not only rare but also the only case reported thus far to the best of our knowledge, Sood et al. described Type 1 equivalent with epiphyseal injuries of both radius and ulna Osada et al. also described injury pattern same as Sood et al. with epiphyseal separation in both distal radius and ulna. Our case was slightly different than above two in that distally, there was ulna shaft fracture with Salter Harris Type 2 epiphyseal separation in the radius.
An 11-year-old, right-hand dominant boy presented in casualty with a history of fall one day back with pain, swelling and deformity in the left forearm with bleeding from left forearm and loss of movement of fingers and thumb of the left hand. On examination, there was a wound of size one centimeter on mid-forearm over the ulnar aspect. Extension of fingers and thumb at metacarpophalangeal joints was lost with intact sensations suggestive of posterior interosseus nerve involvement. No vascular was deficit was present. X-rays were performed which suggested type two epiphyseal separation proximal radius with fracture shaft ulna with lateral angulation in elbow and proximal forearm. Radiocapitellar joint congruity was maintained in the views performed. X-rays of wrist suggested fracture both bones distal forearm epiphysis in distal radius and distal shaft in ulna. The patient was operated with toileting, debridement, and open reduction of proximal ulnar fracture with K-wire. Proximal radius epiphyseal separation was approached by Kocher approach and fixed with two K-wires, while for distal radius epiphyseal separation open reduction and internal fixation was performed. Follow-up of the patient showed posterior interosseus nerve recovery and subsequent union of all fractures with good functional outcome.
This type of lesion is rare in children probably because the annular ligament is relatively lax and the radial head dislocates more easily anteriorly, rather than occurrence of fracture as seen in our case, and associated fracture of distal forearm is a very rare injury.
我们报告一例11岁男孩的1型类孟氏骨折损伤,桡骨头关节面完整,同时合并桡骨远端骨骺骨折和尺骨远端骨干骨折。儿童中孟氏骨折或类孟氏骨折合并同侧前臂骨折的病例较少,据我们所知,我们所报告的损伤模式不仅罕见,而且是迄今为止唯一的病例。苏德等人描述了1型类孟氏骨折合并桡骨和尺骨骨骺损伤,小田等人也描述了与苏德等人相同的损伤模式,即桡骨远端和尺骨远端骨骺分离。我们的病例与上述两例略有不同,在远端,尺骨干骨折合并桡骨Salter Harris 2型骨骺分离。
一名11岁、惯用右手的男孩因一天前摔倒前来急诊,主诉左前臂疼痛、肿胀、畸形,左前臂出血,左手手指和拇指活动丧失。检查发现,前臂中段尺侧有一个1厘米大小的伤口。掌指关节处手指和拇指伸展功能丧失,但感觉正常,提示骨间后神经受累。未发现血管损伤。X线检查显示桡骨近端2型骨骺分离,尺骨干骨折,肘部和前臂近端有外侧成角。所拍摄的X线片显示桡骨头关节面完整。腕部X线片显示桡骨远端骨骺和尺骨远端骨干骨折。患者接受了清创、冲洗,并对尺骨近端骨折进行了切开复位和克氏针内固定。采用Kocher入路处理桡骨近端骨骺分离,并用两根克氏针固定,而对于桡骨远端骨骺分离则进行了切开复位内固定。患者随访显示骨间后神经恢复,所有骨折均愈合,功能恢复良好。
这种类型的损伤在儿童中很少见,可能是因为环状韧带相对松弛,桡骨头更容易向前脱位,而不是像我们病例中那样发生骨折,并且前臂远端合并骨折是一种非常罕见的损伤。