Jin Cai De, Kim Moo Hyun, Kim Soo Jin, Lee Kwang Min, Kim Tae Hyung, Cho Young-Rak, Serebruany Victor L
Department of Cardiology, College of Medicine, Dong-A University, Busan, Republic of Korea.
Cardiology. 2017;137(2):83-91. doi: 10.1159/000455824. Epub 2017 Feb 8.
The optimal strategy to manage chronic total occlusion (CTO) remains unclear. The Japanese CTO multicenter registry (J-CTO) score is an established tool for predicting successful recanalization. However, it does not take into account nonangiographic predictors for final technique success. In the present study, we designed and tested a scoring model called the Busan single-center CTO registry (B-CTO) score combining clinical and angiographic characteristics to predict successful CTO recanalization in Korean patients.
Prospectively enrolled CTO patients (n = 438) undergoing coronary intervention (1999-2015) were assessed. The B-CTO score comprises 6 independent predictors: age 60-74 years and lesion length ≥20 mm were assigned 1 point each, while age ≥75 years, female gender, lesion location in the right coronary artery, blunt stump, and bending >45° were assigned 2 points each. For each predictor, the points assigned were based on the associated odds ratio by multivariate analysis. The lesions were classified into 4 groups according to the summation of points scored to assess the probability of successful CTO recanalization: easy (score 0-1), intermediate (score 2-3), difficult (score 4-5), and very difficult (score ≥6). CTO opening was designated as the primary endpoint regardless of the interventional era or the skill of the operator.
The final success rate for B-CTO was 81.1%. The probability of successful recanalization for patient groups classified as easy (n = 64), intermediate (n = 148), difficult (n = 134), and very difficult (n = 92) was 95.3, 86.5, 79.1 and 65.2%, respectively (p for trend <0.001). When compared to the J-CTO, the B-CTO score demonstrated a significant improvement in discrimination as indicated by the area under the receiver-operator characteristic curve (AUC 0.083; 95% CI 0.025-0.141), with a positive integrated discrimination improvement of 0.042 and a net reclassification improvement of 56.0%.
The B-CTO score has been designed and validated in Korean patients with native coronary CTO and is an improved tool for predicting successful recanalization. Wider application of the B-CTO score remains to be explored.
慢性完全闭塞(CTO)的最佳治疗策略仍不明确。日本CTO多中心注册研究(J-CTO)评分是预测再通成功的既定工具。然而,它未考虑最终技术成功的非血管造影预测因素。在本研究中,我们设计并测试了一种名为釜山单中心CTO注册研究(B-CTO)评分的模型,该模型结合临床和血管造影特征来预测韩国患者CTO再通成功。
对前瞻性纳入的接受冠状动脉介入治疗(1999 - 2015年)的CTO患者(n = 438)进行评估。B-CTO评分包含6个独立预测因素:年龄60 - 74岁和病变长度≥20 mm各赋值1分,而年龄≥75岁、女性、右冠状动脉病变部位、钝端残端以及迂曲>45°各赋值2分。对于每个预测因素,所赋分值基于多变量分析中的相关优势比。根据得分总和将病变分为4组,以评估CTO再通成功的概率:容易(得分0 - 1)、中等(得分2 - 3)、困难(得分4 - 5)和非常困难(得分≥6)。无论介入时代或术者技术如何,CTO开通均被指定为主要终点。
B-CTO的最终成功率为81.1%。分类为容易(n = 64)、中等(n = 148)、困难(n = 134)和非常困难(n = 92)的患者组再通成功的概率分别为95.3%、86.5%、79.1%和65.2%(趋势p<0.001)。与J-CTO相比,B-CTO评分在鉴别能力上有显著改善,表现为受试者工作特征曲线下面积(AUC 0.083;95%CI 0.025 - 0.141),正向综合鉴别改善为0.042,净重新分类改善为56.0%。
B-CTO评分已在韩国原发性冠状动脉CTO患者中设计并验证,是预测再通成功的一种改进工具。B-CTO评分的更广泛应用仍有待探索。