Otterman Gabriel, Jalsenius Marie, Maguire Sabine, Sarkadi Anna, Janson Staffan
Department of Women's and Children's Health, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden.
Karolinska University Hospital, Solna, Sweden.
Acta Paediatr. 2017 Jul;106(7):1110-1117. doi: 10.1111/apa.13779. Epub 2017 Feb 28.
Little is known about the organisation of child maltreatment practice in Europe. We therefore explored medical child protection systems and training across Europe.
An online survey was completed by physicians working in child maltreatment, identified through professional organisations in 28 member countries of the European Union, Iceland, Norway and Switzerland in 2012-2013. Respondents were questioned regarding management of suspected child maltreatment, mandatory reporting, professional training, patient referral and physician roles in multidisciplinary investigations. Responses underwent a narrative synthesis and descriptive enumerations.
The survey was completed by 88 individuals, unevenly distributed in 22 of 31 countries. Physicians were mandated to report child maltreatment in 16 of 22 countries. All of 88 responding physicians described multidisciplinary involvement in the clinical and forensic management of suspected child maltreatment. Practitioners involved in physical examinations included general physicians, paediatricians, forensic medical examiners, gynaecologists and paediatric surgeons. Paediatricians were required to undergo child protection training according to 30 of 86 respondents in 14 of 22 countries.
This survey demonstrates that there were wide variations in the organisation of child maltreatment paediatrics in Europe. The differing legislative frameworks and models of care are pertinent to consider when comparing epidemiology of maltreatment reported from across European countries.
对于欧洲儿童虐待诊疗工作的组织情况,人们了解甚少。因此,我们对欧洲各地的儿童医疗保护系统和培训情况展开了探索。
2012 - 2013年,通过欧盟28个成员国、冰岛、挪威和瑞士的专业组织,确定了从事儿童虐待诊疗工作的医生,并让他们完成了一项在线调查。调查询问了受访者关于疑似儿童虐待的管理、强制报告、专业培训、患者转诊以及医生在多学科调查中的角色等问题。对回复进行了叙述性综合分析和描述性枚举。
88人完成了调查,分布在31个国家中的22个国家,分布不均衡。在22个国家中的16个国家,医生被要求报告儿童虐待情况。88位回复的医生都描述了在疑似儿童虐待的临床和法医管理中多学科的参与情况。参与体格检查的从业者包括全科医生、儿科医生、法医、妇科医生和小儿外科医生。在22个国家中的14个国家,86位受访者中有30位表示儿科医生需要接受儿童保护培训。
这项调查表明,欧洲儿童虐待儿科的组织情况存在很大差异。在比较欧洲各国报告的虐待流行病学情况时,不同的立法框架和护理模式是需要考虑的相关因素。